iho-ohi / S-129-Product-Specification

IHO Repository to discuss technical issues of development of S-129 Product Specification.
6 stars 4 forks source link

FC 20231012 is incompatible with S-100 5.x #1

Closed rmalyankar closed 8 months ago

rmalyankar commented 8 months ago

The XML FC currently in the 20231012 folder does not validate with the S-100 5.0.0 FC schema, the namespaces and schemaLocation have not been updated. The files in the "pre-1.1.0" folder appear to have them right (though I checked only the 20230727 file).

The version number of the FC should correspond to the S-129 edition, not the S-100 edition.

jrhee01 commented 8 months ago

thanks @rmalyankar. The namespaces and schemaLocation should be consistent across the 3 under the "pre-1.1.0" folder. I will look at uploading a new copy consistent with the 20231012 version, but with the namespaces and schemaLocation corrected.

jrhee01 commented 8 months ago

FC initially under the 20231012 folder has been renamed and relocated to "1.1.0/FC/S-129_1_1_0_FC.XML". Updates have then been made to this FC for the namespaces and schemaLocation.

rmalyankar commented 8 months ago

There are other schema-validation problems, I corrected them as I understood the intent and submitted a pull request with the corrected file. Up to you @jrhee01 to review the differences and accept or reject as you think best.

Please note, I have not checked anything other than whether it validates with the S-100 5.0.0 FC schema.

jrhee01 commented 8 months ago

many thanks for the pick ups @rmalyankar. I should've seen your comment first before pushing my own changes, as I also noticed:

  1. mismatch b/w "UnderKeelClearancePurpose" vs "UnderKeelClearancePurposeType",
  2. mismatch b/w "UnderKeelClearanceCalculationRequested" vs "UnderKeelClearanceCalculationRequested".
  3. letter inconsistency in the 2 attribute names

The actual attribute names are without "Type", so I have merged our changes accordingly.

Thanks for adding S100FC:productId.

rmalyankar commented 8 months ago

Edition 1.1.0 FC passes XML-schema validation with S-100 Edition 5.0.0 schemas now. I have not checked anything other than XMLschema-validity.