Item No. | Feature affected | Frequency of comments | Comment | S-129 chair comments/questions
-- | -- | -- | -- | --
1 | UnderKeelClearancePlan | 4 | Boundary transparency not necessary | Overall, it appears some were happy with the transparency of the boundary line, while some considered it unnecessary. Current draft S-129 PC applies a 50% transparency. If the general opinion is that the transparency is unnecessary (i.e. doesn’t make a difference with or without), rather than that the transparency reduces navigational safety for end users, then perhaps we could just retain the 50% transparency? Would be great to get further feedback.
2 | UnderKeelClearancePlan | 3 | "UKCM" text symbol too big | Noted. What extent should we reduce this to? By 0.5mm as suggested by Norway? 0.5mm in what dimension – both x,y?
3 | UnderKeelClearanceControlPoint | 3 | Circle and bow-tie too big | Noted. What extent should we reduce this to? By 0.5mm as suggested by Norway? Or is there a "standard" circular ENC symbol that we can use as size reference?
4 | UnderKeelClearancePlan | 2 | Distance b/w "UKCM" annotation can be increased to reduce clutter | Noted.
5 | UnderKeelClearanceControlPoint | 1 | 50% transparency recommended to avoid masking other features (e.g. soundings) | Noted.
6 | UnderKeelClearanceNonNavigableArea | 1 | Night mode colour fill (#390e16) indistinguishable | Noted. But colours follow existing S-100 colour tokens. Hesitant to explore other colours and deviate from the established S-100 colour tokens
7 | UnderKeelClearanceAlmostNonNavigableArea | 1 | Night mode colour fill (#301705) indistinguishable | Noted. But colours follow existing S-100 colour tokens. Hesitant to explore other colours and deviate from the established S-100 colour tokens
8 | UnderKeelClearanceAlmostNonNavigableArea | 1 | Orange colour scheme conflicts with planned route, and other UI elements such as scale bar and cursor | An orange colour scheme is still the most suitable for UnderKeelClearanceAlmostNonNavigableArea. Is there a particular orange colour token, suitable for conveying warnings/alerts, which the NCWG would recommend? I had a brief look at the GOLDN colour token, which may provide an alternative that we can explore, but the DUSK and NIGHT modes for this don’t (yet) seem to exist.
<html xmlns:v="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:vml" xmlns:o="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" xmlns:w="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:word" xmlns:m="http://schemas.microsoft.com/office/2004/12/omml" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40">
Item No. | Feature affected | Frequency of comments | Comment | S-129 chair comments/questions -- | -- | -- | -- | -- 1 | UnderKeelClearancePlan | 4 | Boundary transparency not necessary | Overall, it appears some were happy with the transparency of the boundary line, while some considered it unnecessary. Current draft S-129 PC applies a 50% transparency. If the general opinion is that the transparency is unnecessary (i.e. doesn’t make a difference with or without), rather than that the transparency reduces navigational safety for end users, then perhaps we could just retain the 50% transparency? Would be great to get further feedback. 2 | UnderKeelClearancePlan | 3 | "UKCM" text symbol too big | Noted. What extent should we reduce this to? By 0.5mm as suggested by Norway? 0.5mm in what dimension – both x,y? 3 | UnderKeelClearanceControlPoint | 3 | Circle and bow-tie too big | Noted. What extent should we reduce this to? By 0.5mm as suggested by Norway? Or is there a "standard" circular ENC symbol that we can use as size reference? 4 | UnderKeelClearancePlan | 2 | Distance b/w "UKCM" annotation can be increased to reduce clutter | Noted. 5 | UnderKeelClearanceControlPoint | 1 | 50% transparency recommended to avoid masking other features (e.g. soundings) | Noted. 6 | UnderKeelClearanceNonNavigableArea | 1 | Night mode colour fill (#390e16) indistinguishable | Noted. But colours follow existing S-100 colour tokens. Hesitant to explore other colours and deviate from the established S-100 colour tokens 7 | UnderKeelClearanceAlmostNonNavigableArea | 1 | Night mode colour fill (#301705) indistinguishable | Noted. But colours follow existing S-100 colour tokens. Hesitant to explore other colours and deviate from the established S-100 colour tokens 8 | UnderKeelClearanceAlmostNonNavigableArea | 1 | Orange colour scheme conflicts with planned route, and other UI elements such as scale bar and cursor | An orange colour scheme is still the most suitable for UnderKeelClearanceAlmostNonNavigableArea. Is there a particular orange colour token, suitable for conveying warnings/alerts, which the NCWG would recommend? I had a brief look at the GOLDN colour token, which may provide an alternative that we can explore, but the DUSK and NIGHT modes for this don’t (yet) seem to exist.