Closed ijyliu closed 3 years ago
I agree that we should throw the beta tables out.
That leaves these as characteristics that we can vary (along with the purpose that they serve in the paper):
So basically the sim section should go like:
Does that seem like the plan? Maybe I should swap 3 and 4?
That would work. Though I would say you maybe don't need 3. Especially if we can add like a quick theoretical note on the exponential transform and/or curse of too many instruments
Okay, let me write that up now.
I just pushed the changes. I ended up putting just the p-charts in the appendix (for every N value and for both exp and no exp). Could someone read through my section to make sure it all seems reasonable?
I am reading and editing now
On Fri, Jun 4, 2021 at 4:18 PM marionoro @.***> wrote:
I just pushed the changes. I ended up putting just the p-charts in the appendix (for every N value and for both exp and no exp). Could someone read through my section to make sure it all seems reasonable?
— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ijyliu/ECMA-31330-Project/issues/93#issuecomment-854977348, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AQCGE4O4ZR6NJ5PUIRYHXIDTREYLBANCNFSM46CXNA2Q .
I think we will want to clean up this paragraph as it seems a little long and rambly:
but other than that the sim section now looks pretty good
I ended up putting just the p-charts in the appendix (for every N value and for both exp and no exp).
So you didn't think the rho charts added anything really? I guess that seems plausible.
I know that like the beta charts didn't show much at all of course. And probably no need to mention the me_cov stuff.
I made some changes:
Yeah, I figured that 10 charts would be too many in the Appendix, so I didn't include the rho charts. I'm open to being persuaded otherwise though.
Yeah, I figured that 10 charts would be too many in the Appendix, so I didn't include the rho charts. I'm open to being persuaded otherwise though.
Ok yeah the rho chart we have in the main text is pretty good.
Let me read over that new paragraph, in the mean time I guess you should proofread everything else
Alright, made some revisions. But overall I think this issue is closed. I feel pretty good about the sim section, just need to work on everything else now.
Here's what I suggest. Pick two tables to put in the main text:
I don't think the beta tables show much so maybe we should completely toss those out.