Open NicholasFlamy opened 8 months ago
One more media item in #2765: https://github.com/immich-app/immich/assets/8555749/94ab43ec-4535-4bd2-9b78-bb5608f0dff2
FYI, this is still the case. Just did a check up.
Still it's not quite there, Google Photos still does it better. It has this sort of a motorized effect. Description of what Google Photos is doing that makes it better:
The bug
The left or right swipe animation is too long and often is a problem when attempting to take other actions in the mobile app. This has been a reported problem to users in the past but they did not understand the cause of their problem. Zoom issue: #2765 Discussion relating to this: #4005
The OS that Immich Server is running on
N/A
Version of Immich Server
N/A
Version of Immich Mobile App
All versions in the past year or more
Platform with the issue
Your docker-compose.yml content
Your .env content
Reproduction steps
Additional information
Everything was tested on the Immich demo server. The screen recordings of Immich and Google Photos are on my Samsung Galaxy S21 5G running Android 13 OneUI 5.1.
Immich acts completely independent of the animation scale developer options: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/994044917355663450/1182411884255793264/Screen_Recording_20231207_150150.mp4?ex=658dd461&is=657b5f61&hm=b66bac91ffc3d8b8af51d52cb7c02d57d500fe24146745a4bf9a7c9aad22b643&
Right/Left swipe in Google Photos is independent, but up/down is dependent on the developer option: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/994044917355663450/1182412597870461038/Screen_Recording_20231207_150423_Photos.mp4?ex=658dd50b&is=657b600b&hm=14873f4ca6bd152dfc1a628aaf24574c2844d577a72db36a63d1ad0b7f2afbfe&
If I swipe up or down while the swipe left or right animation is playing in Google Photos it counts as a left or right swipe so that is the same as Immich but this animation is much shorter in Google Photos so I was only able to do this by purposefully trying to go too fast: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/994044917355663450/1182418282423275662/Screen_Recording_20231207_152708_Photos.mp4?ex=658dda56&is=657b6556&hm=09ec31da069106a4a43a7c083b56b62566ff11e6e97f3d672ed91e004b6b34d7&
Some more demonstrations: https://photos.app.goo.gl/RonpTwFi8dts2Hky7
The animation speed is slow, and also Immich has a Jelloey effect where you can swipe past the image and it comes back whereas Google Photos (as well as other Gallery apps like Samsung Gallery) smooth this animation and don't let it go past the image: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/994044917355663450/1182431811364716594/Screen_Recording_20231207_162135.mp4?ex=658de6f0&is=657b71f0&hm=8d1b7935ac41aadb32b2ee01127b4b3846285221646b6de0a7342f1db51ae9f1&
The following videos are (as is visible since I videoed the screen) on an iPhone 8+. It is running iOS 16.7.2 and the latest Immich app on the demo server The full video demonstrating the issue occurring on the iOS app identically to on Android: https://photos.app.goo.gl/LYgpue1ocJyBFVsP9
The clip highlighting the slow animation and how the image is almost but not completely lined up in frame: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/994044917355663450/1182437154329215056/20231207_163248_2.mp4?ex=658debea&is=657b76ea&hm=ab4577efd885b1b21e86c9bc91967285025768ff612457429846e2bf8557fed3&