Open doug9876 opened 5 months ago
Can you provide a sample file? I would like to test it.
Thanks for the response. I've attached a zip file containing four files, IMG_0160.jpeg and IMG_0160.mov are files downloaded from iCloud photos not using "export as unmodified original" which then downloads as a jpeg rather than heic and preserves the aspect ratio of the photo, IMG_0163.heic and IMG_0163.mov used "export as unmodified original" which seems to change the aspect ratio by making the photo narrower.
The reason I included both is that when photos are uploaded through the Immich app on the iphone the aspect ratio is preserved.
Interestingly when these photos are added to Immich through the web UI (rather than iphone app) the live photo plays correctly on both the web UI and iphone app without being shrunk or the static parts on each side (regardless of if was "export as unmodified original" and aspect ration changes).
So to me it seems like the issue happens somewhere in the iphone upload.
I expect this also means that uploading the photos through the web won't replicate the issue, as it should work correctly.
Let me know if I can provide any further information testing.
Thanks!
The bug
When uploading live photos through the iphone app there are two issues:
1) When viewing the photo on the iphone in landscape mode on each side of the video there is a static image of part of the photo.
2) When viewing the same photo on the web interface the video is made narrower.
I've attached a screen recording of viewing the image (and video parts) on the iphone and on my desktop using chrome.
Interestingly when hovering on play icon in the top right the thumbnail of the live photo in the main photo gallery on the web UI the live photo video plays without any width change.
When viewing the same images in the native apple photos library the video parts display as expected, same when viewing through icloud photos on the web browser.
https://github.com/immich-app/immich/assets/11768229/371fdfba-a88b-485e-9f94-f50d70b207d3
https://github.com/immich-app/immich/assets/11768229/5e1d6354-74aa-4560-8eb1-faa6c45a4ff0
The OS that Immich Server is running on
Windows 11
Version of Immich Server
v1.99.0
Version of Immich Mobile App
v1.98.2
Platform with the issue
Your docker-compose.yml content
Your .env content
Reproduction steps
Additional information
No response