search

inab / benchmarking-data-model

OpenEBench Benchmarking Data Model repository
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
2 stars 7 forks source link

add community_id to the Reference #123

Closed redmitry closed 1 year ago

redmitry commented 3 years ago

Publications (Reference) are global what provokes incertitude in who is allowed to write and update them. Community owners should be able to manage the publications relevant to their submissions.

Another way is to allow all community owners write to the Reference...

jmfernandez commented 3 years ago

If we add _community_id to Reference, we should also include an orig_id_ field, as well as switching to an OpenEBench generated identifier.

redmitry commented 3 years ago

If we add _community_id to Reference, we should also include an orig_id_ field, as well as switching to an OpenEBench generated identifier.

Rationale?

jmfernandez commented 3 years ago

If we add _community_id to Reference, we should also include an orig_id_ field, as well as switching to an OpenEBench generated identifier.

Rationale?

If the Reference entry is associated to a community, but its __id_ is still a DOI or a PubMedId, then the id is "embargoed" by that community, banning other ones from any change on it. So, a solution is allowing more than one Reference entry referring to the same manuscript or digital object, but being managed by the community.

redmitry commented 3 years ago

Yeah. Currently (without community_id) I just allow all community owners add/modify references. Probably we can add community_ids[], but again - who has write permissions?

jmfernandez commented 2 years ago

Yeah. Currently (without community_id) I just allow all community owners add/modify references. Probably we can add community_ids[], but again - who has write permissions?

I guess that only the community managers, who should act as curators.

jmfernandez commented 2 years ago

So, community_ids would be more a list of communities which are involved in some way to that reference than an attribute telling the bibliographic reference is "owned" by those communities.

jmfernandez commented 1 year ago

Fixed at commit 40ee07689f401de0009d5c3a67ce3b4f442de1a7 adding dependable_community_ids, which is optional.