Review of 25 meetnetten-amfibieen-larven-occurrences

[peterdesmet]

IPT dataset: meetnetten-amfibieen-larven-occurrences

event

• [x] datasetName: Update title (see #9)
• [x] samplingProtocol: use "larvae" (see #9)

occ

• [x] lifeStage: lowercase larva. Are there also metamorph indicated as such? If not, do we really need it in the dataset title?

mof

• [x] ph value → ph
• [x] present fish → fish present (first one implies a list of fish, second works better for boolean)
• [x] surface pond → pond surface
• [x] waterquality → water quality
• [x] maximum depth: would change one value so it is a range: <0.5, 0.5-1, 1-1.5 (rather than >1), >1.5
• [x] ph value: has unknown, but I would use an empty value instead, as it is a number field (cf. number of sweeps)?
• [x] waterquality: map slecht (verwaarloosde poel me...) to bad

[DimEvil]

There are 2 similar protocols (25 & 32) they can be lumped. WHEN 'Amfibieën - Larven' THEN 'amphibia larvae count' WHEN 'Amfibieën - Larven en metamorfen' THEN 'amphibia larvae and metamorphs count'

[peterdesmet]

Great! The remaining issues in v1.1:

• [x] EVENT samplingProtocol has the unmapped value Amfibieën - Larven en metamorfen rather than amphibia larvae and metamorphs count
• [x] OCC many occurrences (e.g. INBO:MEETNET:EVENT:200660 don't have an associated event
• [x] OCC lifestage: Larva -> larva en metamorf -> metamorph
• [x] ~OCC scientificName: Pelobates lessonae occurs as well as Pelophylax lessonae. The first is not a known scientific name.~
• [x] OCC taxonRank: Pelophylax esculenta synklepton should be speciesAggregate
• [x] OCC taxonRank: Lissotriton spec. should be genus
• [x] MEAS changes not implemented yet (maybe not yet included in v1.1)
• [ ] MEAS measurementType: translate zoekinspanning to sampling effort and translate values. Maybe it's even better this goes into the event core samplingEffort

[peterdesmet]

v1.2:

• [x] samplingProtocol: suggest "amphibia larvae and metamorphs count"
• [x] measurementType type effort, suggest to change to sampling effort type
• [ ] many measurementValues are unmapped (those that are ok have no mapping suggestion):

measurementType	measurementValue	mapping suggestion
fish present	FALSE
fish present	ja	TRUE
fish present	nee	FALSE
fish present	niet bekeken/niet van toepassing	(NA)
fish present	TRUE
fish present	U	(NA)
fish present	(NA)
maximum depth	>1.5
maximum depth	0-0.5
maximum depth	0.5-1
maximum depth	1-1.5
maximum depth	niet bekeken/niet van toepassing	(NA)
maximum depth	unknown	(NA)
number of sweeps	-4	a negative value?
number of sweeps	0
number of sweeps	10
number of sweeps	12
number of sweeps	13
number of sweeps	15
number of sweeps	18
number of sweeps	2
number of sweeps	20
number of sweeps	25
number of sweeps	3
number of sweeps	30
number of sweeps	4
number of sweeps	40
number of sweeps	5
number of sweeps	6
number of sweeps	7
number of sweeps	8
number of sweeps	9
number of sweeps	(NA)
permanent water column	FALSE
permanent water column	ja	TRUE
permanent water column	nee	FALSE
permanent water column	niet bekeken/niet van toepassing	(NA)
permanent water column	TRUE
permanent water column	(NA)
pH	6
pH	7
pH	8
pH	(NA)
pond surface	<10
pond surface	>400
pond surface	10-100
pond surface	101-250
pond surface	251-400
pond surface	niet bekeken/niet van toepassing	(NA)
pond surface	(NA)
shading	<30%
shading	>60%
shading	30-60%
shading	niet bekeken/niet van toepassing	(NA)
shading	no shade	no shading
shading	no shading
shading	unknown	(empty)
type effort	sweep for larvae only
type effort	sweep for larvae, metamorphs counted on land
type effort	(NA)
water quality	3	???
water quality	average
water quality	bad
water quality	good
water quality	niet bekeken/niet van toepassing	(NA)
water quality	plas verdwenen of volledig verland	pond has disappeared
water quality	unknown	(NA)

[DimEvil]

whip this @peterdesmet

[peterdesmet]

Whipped real good. 💪