search

indico / indico

Indico - A feature-rich event management system, made @ CERN, the place where the Web was born.
https://getindico.io
MIT License
1.74k stars 420 forks source link

unscheduled contributions must NOT be shown under Contribution List #6141

Open maarten-litmaath opened 8 months ago

maarten-litmaath commented 8 months ago

Dear Indico devs, I discovered unscheduled contributions still being shown under Contribution List, while no longer being shown in the Timetable. To get rid of them completely, I had to delete them altogether: that looks a bug to me...

bpedersen2 commented 6 months ago

This is a design decision: The flow is: Abstract ---- accept ---> Contribution ----- schedule ---> Contribution in timetable.

In many fields it is custom that scheduling happens quite late, but you still want to get a list of contributions.

maarten-litmaath commented 6 months ago

OK, but could we have a warning somewhere that there are unscheduled contributions?

ThiefMaster commented 6 months ago

I think in the management contribution list showing them makes perfect sense.

In the public contribution list I don't think we should be showing them, so I tend to agree that it's unwanted behavior if we do right now. But I'd need to check our data if there are any cases where people may have contributions that they want to show up...