inotia00 / ReVanced_Extended

ReVanced Extended Issues/Request repo
729 stars 29 forks source link

suggestion (YT - Watch history): Use toggles instead of radio buttons for the `Watch history type` setting #2283

Closed KobeW50 closed 1 month ago

KobeW50 commented 3 months ago

Application

YouTube

Suggestion description

Problem

"Watch history type" doesn't imply that the options would be between Original, Replace domain, and Block watch history. This can make it difficult for someone trying to block watch history or change the domain.

For example, if someone's watch history doesn't work and they see in the Watch history settings menu that "Watch history may not work due to DNS or VPN", they still will not know that they can fix this in YT RVX.

Solution/Suggestion

Separate the Watch history type setting into two toggles.

Toggle 1: Block watch history

Toggle 2: Replace watch history domain (Only toggleable when toggle 1 is disabled)

This will make it much easier to find these options.

Acknowledgements

YT-Advanced commented 3 months ago

Using toggle may make some confusion for user, since they're not sure if they're turning on the correct settings. In the past, this also happened with the Spoof player parameter type settings.

inotia00 commented 1 month ago

I've been thinking about it for a long time, but it seems better to keep it as is rather than splitting it into two switches