search

input-output-hk / daedalus

The open source cryptocurrency wallet for ada, built to grow with the community
https://daedaluswallet.io/
Apache License 2.0
1.23k stars 296 forks source link

Its urgent - We need a Daedalus Version with low ram usage #3181

Open gitmachtl opened 2 months ago

gitmachtl commented 2 months ago

solution needed for people to migrate off from daedalus

its nice that we have all the new governance stuff, but people are suffering from the lack of support for daedalus for a long time.

many of those can't easily upgrade there systems to 32GB+ of ram. many are not technical experienced to do that on there own if even possible with there current system.

many don't have there seed phrase anymore, but could send off there funds to a new wallet. but not if they can't start daedalus anymore.

i have to deal with such people every day. i am an SPO, and we are many times the first ones who gets contacted by frustated users.

i know that daedalus is currently that child that noone wants, but its bad for the ada holders out there tbh.

idea

so an idea came up to at least release a daedalus version that is using an external node for the sync, so people need less ram. cardano-wallet uses the rest.

doable?

at least they could then send of there funds to LACE, ETERNL, etc.

old node problem

current daedalus release uses a very old node v1.35.4. we had some important bugfixes with 1.35.7, a lot of people report crashes with 1.35.4. so thats another point to tackle.

❗ we need to react, now. its getting worse every day we wait.

-- Martin

CryptoBlocks-pro commented 2 months ago

Yeah, as an SPO as well, this comes up for our team as well. Great idea. Eric

btbf commented 2 months ago

This is a very good point! Even in the Japanese community, many people use Daedalus, but there are also many people who don't use dAapps, and we often get inquiries about problems with computer specs. This needs to be resolved immediately.

onyxstakepool commented 2 months ago

Issue #3182 provides a quick fix for Daedalus on MacOS.

OYSTERPOOL commented 2 months ago

I'm also regularly trying to help community members with Daedalus sync issues. A toggle switch to enable connection to an external node would be great to enable people to send their funds to a new wallet in the cases of lost seed phrase.

kevinhammond commented 2 months ago

We do have a version of the node in preparation that will limit RAM usage by using out-of-memory storage. It's not quite production ready - we're looking for some people to help test it on a DevNet.

kevinhammond commented 2 months ago

I'm also regularly trying to help community members with Daedalus sync issues. A toggle switch to enable connection to an external node would be great to enable people to send their funds to a new wallet in the cases of lost seed phrase.

I'll pass this on

thevictor13 commented 2 months ago

If I recall correctly, back in the day newer Daedalus versions could import wallets from the previous ones. As an alternative solution to inaccessible wallets due to the RAM limitation it would be nice to have a tool to extract those wallets to import them in a light wallet?

vhulchenko-iohk commented 1 month ago

Hi everyone,

Thank you for reporting this issue and providing additional context.

I'm Volo, a Product Manager at IOG, responsible for maintaining the Daedalus wallet.

I'm currently learning about Daedalus wallet users, their issues, pain points, and needs. If you are a Daedalus wallet user or have any insights to share, I would love to speak with you. Feel free to set up a 30-minute call at your convenience using my calendar: https://calendly.com/volodymyr-hulchenko-iohk/30min

Looking forward to talking with you.

Best regards, Volo