Closed jensscheerlinck closed 8 years ago
Proposed resolution: First part of "Notes" duplicates #8. I believe Requirement 18 could be read to mean that the record returned shalle be a valid ISO 19139 record (allowing for ISO 19119 extensions). This seems to be what the ATS test method is getting at. I suggest improving the wording:
Purpose: the INSPIRE metadata elements shall be returned in response to a Discover Metadata query in the form of an ISO 19139/19119 metadata record. Test method: validate the response against ats-metadata
Note: A.3.1 is then a pre-requisite of several of the other tests. Note: discussion on split of responsibility between ats-metadata and ats-discovery-service
This issue has been extracted from the issue list on:https://ies-svn.jrc.ec.europa.eu/issues/2685
Comment
Testability + Ambiguity: both the test purpose and test method need more details and clarification in order to arrive at a test case which 'is sufficient to enable a test verdict to be assigned unambiguously to each potentially observable test outcome'
Notes: Unique identification (name) for this tests needs to be added (e.g. A.1.3 Metadata request).
NR IS should be added as reference (Annex II Part A 2.1)
XPATH expression is missing