inspirehep / inspire-next

The INSPIRE repo.
https://inspirehep.net
GNU General Public License v3.0
59 stars 69 forks source link

Search result for literature record 'Higgs particles' seems too verbose #2947

Open Dinika opened 6 years ago

Dinika commented 6 years ago

The search result for record #419131 on labs: screenshot from 2017-11-13 12-07-00

The search result for the same record looks like so on my local installation of inspire: screenshot from 2017-11-13 12-13-31

However, when records 969512, 969511, and 969510 are imported locally then the search result is similar to the one in labs (1st picture).

What should the search result for this record really be?

(Currently if I change the test condition in angular from: <div ng-if="record.display.publication_info[0].journal_title || record.display.conference_info[0].conference_title" >

to <div ng-if="record.display.publication_info[0].journal_title.length > 0 || record.display.conference_info[0].conference_title.length > 0" >

then the result is similar to picture 2)

jacquerie commented 6 years ago

Legacy is not doing much better: https://inspirehep.net/record/419131. Probably something for @inspirehep/inspire-content to look at.

jacquerie commented 6 years ago

(Currently if I change the test condition in angular from:

<div ng-if="record.display.publication_info[0].journal_title ||
record.display.conference_info[0].conference_title" >

to

<div ng-if="record.display.publication_info[0].journal_title > 0 ||
record.display.conference_info[0].conference_title > 0" >

then the result is similar to picture 2)

We should really move away from this pattern of hiding data problems under the UI carpet: it's much better to fail loudly and clearly now than having subtle issues later (for example, when matching references).

ksachs commented 6 years ago

I assume this is not a question concerning ES but display formats.

The metadata are tricky in this case, 3 conferences were published in one proceedings. I would modify the metadata. Instead of

000419131 773__ $$c95-224$$tTalk given at$$wC95-08-30$$xe+ e- Linear Collisions 1995:95-224
000419131 773__ $$c95-224$$tTalk given at$$wC95-06-02$$xe+ e- Linear Collisions 1995:95-224 
000419131 773__ $$c95-224$$tTalk given at$$wC95-02-04$$xe+ e- Linear Collisions 1995:95-224
000419131 773__ $$xIn *Annecy/Gran Sasso/Hamburg 1995, e+ e- collisions at TeV energies: The physics potential. Pt. D* 95-97

I would reduce it to

000419131 773__ $$0433635$$c95-224

and take the info from the proceedings record instead of the conferences, could you do that? Just the arXiv reference is not enough.