invernyx / md11-bugs

The official bug tracker for the TFDi Design MD-11
https://tfdidesign.com/md11.php
25 stars 2 forks source link

[BUG] - PFD ISSUE SIGNIFICANT FPS DROP ON SCREEN #1551

Closed Viralwhite closed 1 month ago

Viralwhite commented 2 months ago

Describe the bug

While using the AP, the PFD and other screens appear to have a significant FPS drop. When this happens, the autopilot goes absolutely nuts and manual control is required. This will sometimes last seconds, and other times last minutes. I can seem to consistently reproduce it when flying into KSDF on the MAUDD6 arrival for 17R. In this case, I was parallel to the numbers when it happened and it lasted for approximately 60 seconds and then resolved. I was able to land the aircraft. I'm getting this on almost every flight, but I've been consistently flying into SDF or ATL. Both airports I seem to have the issue. Not sure if this is a conflict with something or another issue. The sim was running at 100fps in this instance and everything else performed fine, just not the screens.

Expected behaviour

The PFD and other screens should never have this issue. Expected behavior is that it'll always work.

Evidence

https://streamable.com/qe7pe0

Simulator

Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 (MSFS)

Crash

No

Agreement

09tir98 commented 2 months ago

I have experienced the same thing twice. Both on approach to Dubai. Performance in sim was fine, 30+ fps. But the displays were suttering and the plane was pitching up and down a lot, both with autoflight on, and in manual flight. Resolved itself after 20 seconds or so both times.

ValkyPouet commented 2 months ago

Same issue here, it randomly occures during flight for no reasons the displays starts to stutter and the plane become crazy for less than a minute

joon44 commented 2 months ago

Apparently a Simconnect issue and it happens in other addons too.

Viralwhite commented 2 months ago

What I’m struggling with is we have plenty of people in our VA who are not seeing this issue at all and haven’t seen it through the entire CE launch. Me on the other hand, I’ve seen it since day 1, but only now getting around to really doing anything about it because of my schedule. My question is, why is my simconnect causing an issue and not for others? I’ve got a beefy system with plenty of overhead, so I know it’s not that. I’m swine who likes to compare issues like this and I try to use process of elimination. If I can do 10 flights and have the issue on every flight, but my buddy can do 20 flights and never have it, that tells me we have some sort of configuration difference that’s causing it, but correct me if I’m wrong, simconnect can’t be updated in any way?

Viralwhite commented 2 months ago

I just want to point out that anytime I fly into KSDF, at some point on the arrival this bug seems to happen. I've tried multiple arrivals and every time this seems to happen into SDF. Did a flight from SDF-MKE and everything was fine. So there's at least one consistency. Did a complete nose dive on the arrival.

Yttrium89 commented 2 months ago

Reported the same issue in TFDi discord and was told it was Asobo's fault and that the issue affects other aircraft, which I honestly struggle to believe based on my own experience. I have had WASM crashes in other aircraft, but never this type of (apparently simconnect) issue - only with the TFDi MD-11. Honestly this aircraft should not be taken on VATSIM with this issue. I have reproduced this issue on approach to ILS 20R into PAFA (Fairbanks). It always seems to occur when on HDG SEL and near the approach phase of flight. I highly suspect it is dependent on the airport you fly into.

Viralwhite commented 2 months ago

I was able to reproduce this error twice this evening. Both times flying from KMKE-KSDF. The issue occurred in the same location both times which was between FRIZN and ONCOD on the FRIZN5 arrival, 35L transition. The first flight I did online and the first flight I did offline. Below I've pasted all the information I can provide. I also recorded the second flight from start to finish. In the video, you'll be able to see at the 59m 03s mark, the aircraft begins to oscillate up and down and then it becomes obvious what's going on. I'm only seeing this bug on arrival/departure as it was said above.

1st Flight KMKE-KSDF: UECKR6 DELHI/N0503F290 RAMSE FRIZN5 / 35L Transition / BRBON IAF Apps being used: vpilot client, TFDI smartcars, FS2FF, FSUIPC and GSX Pro Issue started after FRIZN but before ONCOD on the arrival

2nd Flight KMKE-KSDF: UECKR6 DELHI/N0503F290 RAMSE FRIZN5 / 35L Transition / BRBON IAF Apps being used: FSUIPC Issue also started after FRIZN but before ONCOD on the arrival. See video here (Still uploading as of 2244 est 7/5) - You can see the issue at the 59m 03s mark: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=coSM0lf72vo

Here is a list of every mod in my community folder - Just in case anyone sees something that's a conflict or can compare to what they have that might be causing the issue. aerosoft-airport-edlp-paderborn aerosoft-crj Axonos KJAC Jackson Hole axoonos-kric-richmond-airport bmworldamsim-koak-oakland carenado-aircraft-ct182t-skylane-g1000 carenado-aircraft-ct182-skyland-g1000CVT cj4-livery_N171CN dominicdesignteam-kaus-airport dominicdesignteam-kindairport doublet-kphf-airport drzewieckidesign-chicagomidway drzewieckidesign-kbfi drzewieckidesign-kdca drzewieckidesign-kewr drzewieckidesign-krnt ffx-airport-kdpa-chicago ffx-hjet flightbeam-airport-kmsp flightbeam-airport-ksfo-san-francisco flightbeam-airport-nzaa-auckland flightbeam-kiad flyhigh-airport-kisp-islip flyhigh-airport-kjax-jacksonville flytampa-amsterdam flytampagg-boston flytampa-toronta fsdreamteam-airport-kclt-charlotte fsdreamteam-airport-keyw-keywest fsdreamteam-airport-kiah-houston fsdreamteam-airport-ksdf-louisville fsdreamteam-airport-gsx-pro fsdreamteam-airport-gsx-world-of-jetways fsltl-traffic-base fsreborn-fsr500-livery-N27KGDynamic fsuipc-lvar-module iblueyonder-airport-kdal-dallas-love-field inibuilds-a300-f-GE-UPS-149 inibuilds-a300-f-UPS-173 inibuilds-aircraft-a300-600 inibuilds-airport-egkk-gatwick inibuilds-airport-egll-heathrow inibuilds-airport-kbuf-buffalo inibuilds-airport-kdtw-detroit inibuilds-airport-kjfk-newyork inibuilds-airport-klax-losangeles inibuilds-airport-kmke-milwaukee inibuilds-airport-kokc-oklahomacity inibuilds-airport-kpsp-palmsprings inibuilds-airport-ksat-san-antonio inibuilds-airport-omdb-dubai inibuilds-airport-omdu-skydrive-dubai inibuilds-airport-phnl-honolulu Ither-NoHandleBar livery-carenado-t182t-n203db livery-fsr500-n392ma livery-fsr500-piper-branding lvfr-kbdl lvfr-kbwi lvfr-kfll lvfr-kmsy lvfr-ksan lvfr-kmia maccosim-mmun mkstudios-airport-eidw-dublin mkstudios-airport-klga-laguardia mkstudios-airport-kphl-Philadelphia navigraph-navdata navigraph-navdata-base noolaero-module-vdgs orbx-airport-kbur-holywood-burbank orbx-airport-kcrw-yeager orbx-pakt-ketchikan pacsim-kgsp-greer pacsim-saltlakecity pmdg-aircraft-77w pmdg-aircraft-77w-liveries pmdg-aircraft-737 pmdg-aircraft-737-liveries pmdg-aircraft-738 pmdg-aircraft-738-liveries pmdg-aircraft-739 pmdg-aircraft-739-liveries pyreegue-airport-egph-edinburgh rwprofiles-airport-ksgf-springfield simwings-airport-panc-anchorage skyward-aircraft-da50 stealthyduck-airport-kafw-ft-worth tfdidesign-aircraft-efb tfdidesign-aircraft-md11-tfdidesign-aircraft-md11-N260UP txnsim-airport-khou-houston verticalsim-airport-kboi-boise verticalsim-airport-kmyr-myrtle-beach verticalsim-airport--koma-omaha verticalsim-airport-kont-ontario verticalsim-airport-kpie-st-petersburg-clearwater verticalsim-airport-kpvu-provo verticalsim-airport-ksyr-syracuse verticalsim-airport--ktpa-tampa xbaw-soundset-152 xbaw-soundset-crj xometry-airport-kmdt-harrisburg xometry-eaglecounty xwindstuios-airport-krfd-rockford

zazaboeing commented 2 months ago

Same here, on every flight. Multiple times when approaching complex airport sceneries, even with a very decent hardware. Plane is unusable right now.

zazaboeing commented 2 months ago

Apparently a Simconnect issue and it happens in other addons too.

Not on my system, and with hundreds of addons. Only with the md11

joon44 commented 2 months ago

Apparently a Simconnect issue and it happens in other addons too.

Not on my system, and with hundreds of addons. Only with the md11

Not on YOUR system. Luckily not on my system either. I've had it total of 2 times in over 400 hours of flying it so its very rare to me. BUT I had it many many times with the Leonardo MD82 with only quarter of the time. It has also been reported with the PMDG 737 and 777. Why it happens so much to some people, I dont know.

Viralwhite commented 2 months ago

Apparently a Simconnect issue and it happens in other addons too.

Not on my system, and with hundreds of addons. Only with the md11

Not on YOUR system. Luckily not on my system either. I've had it total of 2 times in over 400 hours of flying it so its very rare to me. BUT I had it many many times with the Leonardo MD82 with only quarter of the time. It has also been reported with the PMDG 737 and 777. Why it happens so much to some people, I dont know.

What’s strange for me is I have hundreds of hours with the 737 and I’ve never had this issue with it. I just got done doing about 30+ hours of flying with the 777 doing long hauls and also never saw it there. But yet on almost every MD11 flight I have this occur. Not sure if it’s because of different coding or what. I’m also using a high end pc - 13900k with a 4090. Very strange for sure, but it’s good to see more people are having this issue.

joon44 commented 2 months ago

Apparently a Simconnect issue and it happens in other addons too.

Not on my system, and with hundreds of addons. Only with the md11

Not on YOUR system. Luckily not on my system either. I've had it total of 2 times in over 400 hours of flying it so its very rare to me. BUT I had it many many times with the Leonardo MD82 with only quarter of the time. It has also been reported with the PMDG 737 and 777. Why it happens so much to some people, I dont know.

What’s strange for me is I have hundreds of hours with the 737 and I’ve never had this issue with it. I just got done doing about 30+ hours of flying with the 777 doing long hauls and also never saw it there. But yet on almost every MD11 flight I have this occur. Not sure if it’s because of different coding or what. I’m also using a high end pc - 13900k with a 4090. Very strange for sure, but it’s good to see more people are having this issue.

I havent had it in the 737 either. Its good if the reason can be pinpointed and find out what is triggering it. During CE it was extremely rare. Only now after its released there are people having it 🤷

Yttrium89 commented 2 months ago

Btw it would be nice if you could redo that flight you did to reproduce the issue but this time without KSDF scenery and see if that makes a difference. I wonder if this is kinda like how on xbox, WASM aircraft screens go black on approach into heavy third party airports. Considering that this issue seems to be restricted to certain airports, I think its worth a try to see if the scenery mods themselves are causing the issue with the MD-11

Viralwhite commented 1 month ago

So I completed another flight and this time without FSUIPC. I was able to reproduce the issue again and in the same location! KMKE-KSDF: UECKR6 DELHI/N0503F290 RAMSE FRIZN5 / 35L Transition / BRBON IAF Apps being used: FSUIPC Issue also started after FRIZN but before ONCOD on the arrival.

See video here: https://youtu.be/Up2txrgKZDc

Viralwhite commented 1 month ago

I just completed another flight with nothing in my community folder except the MD11, EFB, and UPS livery. The issue occurred again and in the same spot; however, it only lasted 5 seconds. This leads me to believe the issue is exacerbated by a community folder that has more in it. With that said, I'm unsure what more I can really do.

joon44 commented 1 month ago

I did the same MKE-SDF flight and it didnt happen to me. We really need tfdi to look into it

Viralwhite commented 1 month ago

I did the same MKE-SDF flight and it didnt happen to me. We really need tfdi to look into it

I agree and thank you for taking the time to do that flight and stream it on Twitch. It's unfortunate that you couldn't reproduce it like I could, which makes it even more aggravating. I plan on doing a flight with the PMDG 737 to see if it has a similar issue. I'm also considering deleting my content.xml and .dat files to let the sim rebuild them and see if that cures any issues.

TheFightingRaven commented 1 month ago

as stated by others it's unfortunately out of our control, usually it fixes itself by taking manual control and stabilising the plane

Viralwhite commented 1 month ago

as stated by others it's unfortunately out of our control, usually it fixes itself by taking manual control and stabilising the plane

I want to make sure my reply here is not taken out of context or received as rude or disrespectful, but I really do expect better from you guys. While I understand this bug may not be super widespread to the point that your entire customer base is rioting, I would expect that a bug like this would be left open with attempts to see if maybe it could be minimalized or ongoing work with Asobo could be published here on the issue, especially since there are multiple documented cases from customers on this bug, in discord, AVSIM, and the official MSFS forums with the same issues.

Several of us spent days trying to help reproduce this bug and we found consistencies. There are other 3rd party devs that are having symptoms, but their AP doesn't go absolutely nuts when it happens, just the MD11, so it's less of an issue. I'm not expecting a resolution today, but closing this bug and giving it a status as "not planned" is really defeating for those of us that spent $80 on this product and have been supporting you guys since day 1. I'm CE #90 and I gave you guys a chance. With that said, if this is the expected support and follow up, I will not be a TFDI customer going forward.

turbofandude commented 1 month ago

For anyone reading, I'd like to further clarify our stance here: we're absolutely NOT ignoring the issue. We firmly believe the issue is either with the sim itself, or some, unexplained limitation that Asobo has not communicated with us. We've officially opened up a report with Asobo to get to the bottom of it and that report can be tracked here - https://devsupport.flightsimulator.com/t/simconnect-data-read-rate-suddenly-intermittently-drops/9586

Viralwhite commented 1 month ago

Here is a flight that was completed with the PMDG 737. If you compare my earlier videos to this video, you'll see the issue occurs at the exact same point as the MD11. What's interesting with this issue is that it happens right at the DECEL point on the flight. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJpxpegsMtg

Acktu commented 1 month ago

Just happened to me. PANC Runway 15 PTERS3 STAR. Lasted for about 90 seconds before it went back to normal. Video: https://youtu.be/yyPuxbH9Mnk

zazaboeing commented 1 month ago

And to me again, arriving in LOWW now.