search

iobroker-community-adapters / ioBroker.harmony

Logitech Harmony Adapter for ioBroker
MIT License
14 stars 15 forks source link

Harmony Hub cannot be found after adding a second IP-Adress (Docker) #63

Closed Kunibert-007 closed 10 months ago

Kunibert-007 commented 4 years ago

For my ioBroker-Docker-Image I need a second IP-Adress. After adding it I can't reach the Harmony Hub anymore and in the options I can't specify the right network. Other adapters with network access have no problem.

My configuration: Buanet Docker-Image for ioBroker on Synology NAS Node 10.18.0 Js-controller 2.26 Version 1.22 from Harmony-Adapter

IP-Adress Synology: 192.168.0.3 IP-Adress ioBroker (MACVLAN): 192.168.0.30 IP-Adress Synology Docker-LAN: 172.20.10.1 IP-Adress ioBroker Docker-LAN: 172.20.10.3 IP-Adress Harmony Hub: 192.168.0.71

Log from ioBroker:

image

Don't know how to say the adapter he has to search in the MACVLAN-Network...

AndyGR42 commented 4 years ago

Same issue here. It looks like the adapter ignores any dedicated IP adress.

stratohe commented 3 years ago

I basically have the same issue with one more complication:

The Harmony Hub is in a different VLAN than the docker host. So i have a chain like : DockerLan 172.x.x.x -> DocherHostLan 10.2.x.x and then IOT Lan 10.3.x.x

It is not possible to get the broadcasts over 2 segmenst. Could you please midify in a way where you can specify the IP of the Hub?

David91919 commented 3 years ago

Same issue here, iobroker in docker can't find the hub no matter what I try

pforrmi commented 2 years ago

Same issue... Sadly the plugin is not usable with docker.

baerengraben commented 1 year ago

I have been using the harmony adapter for several years now and am very satisfied with it. When using Adapter and Hub in the same Subnet everything works like a charm.

NOW: As part of security improvements, I have put my WLAN in its own subnet. So the Harmony Hub (192.168.10.x) is now in a different subnet than the ioBroker (192.168.3.x).

The firewall configuration is set:

  1. Harmony Hub has access to a DHCP server that provides an IP address and a valid gateway to the Internet.
  2. Multicasts can propagate across subnets (UDP multicast to the group 224.0.0.1 on port 5224).
  3. TCP traffic on port 8088 can propagate across subnets.

Nevertheless, the Harmony adapter does not find the hub. No matter how I configure the Adapter subnet (config). Some seem to have success with entering the IP (192.168.10.x) directly as the subnet. But that does not work either for me.

I'm sure the hub can communicate with the ioBroker's network (Hub to fakeRoker on same ioBroker still works). It just seems to be a problem with discovery. Is there any way to configure the hub itself directly so that it can operate without discovery first?

By the way, I tested the same with OpenHAB and their Harmony add-on. There, too, a scan across the subnets does not work. But here you can add the hubs manually and then control them as usual.

mcm1957 commented 10 months ago

As this issue is ruther old, I will close here. Please open a new issue if problem still exists and add all relevant release informations: