ioos / registry

Getting data services registered in the IOOS Service Registry
http://ioos.github.io/registry/
2 stars 7 forks source link

catalog application link example #28

Closed jcothran closed 10 years ago

jcothran commented 10 years ago

Is there an example WAF type record and associated searchable service type for more generic 'application' type links? RA's,etc have lots of associated application development as well as more basic THREDDS/OGC web services and would be nice to use the catalog to discover these links and associated summaries also.

jcothran commented 10 years ago

I'll tack onto this similarly with ESRI rest-oriented links like http://129.252.139.110/gsaa/rest/services/SCDNR/MapServer which may expose a number of other layers and services. The source collection table and the main NGDC catalog do not currently provide a search method for application or ESRI type endpoints - are the catalog records forwarded to other catalogs(say using CKAN allowing more faceted search) that allow additional search options on additional service types?

robragsdale commented 10 years ago

Jeremy. We do not have any "applications" registered in the catalog. I don't have an example of application that has been successfully harvested. I know EMMA cannot harvest a html endpoints, so it needs to contain an xml file extension. This has come up once before, but we did not resolve on how to handle.

rsignell-usgs commented 10 years ago

@jcothran, perhaps a bit off topic, but do you have an Ipython notebook that demonstrates using ESRI rest service access to your feature data at http://129.252.139.110/gsaa/rest/services/SCDNR/MapServer?

rsignell-usgs commented 10 years ago

@jcothran, also do you have the ability to turn on WFS services for this data?

emiliom commented 10 years ago

@rsignell-usgs , I'm curious why you ask about WFS (other than it's a bona-fide OGC standard, whereas ESRI REST isn't). I ask b/c I'm interested in WFS support in the IOOS registry-GeoPortal-catalog chain, and in part b/c WFS is not really supported or surfaced yet in that chain.

@jcothran , we're also interested in your original question -- support for "application" link types from WAF-hosted ISO XML metadata records. I've been exploring that in the context of the West Coast Ocean Data Portal (http://portal.westcoastoceans.org), not the IOOS catalog. No clear solutions yet, but I'll prod again next week. I would like to see a link-type for generic online user applications defined over at Cat-Interop (eg, LinkPropertyLookupTable2.csv), but haven't had the time to poke.

rsignell-usgs commented 10 years ago

@emiliom , yes, I asked exactly for that reason: WFS is a OGC standard, and ESRI rest isn't. Plus OGSLib can read WFS: http://nbviewer.ipython.org/github/rsignell-usgs/notebook/blob/2f1b37ae79a828508d56f2a78db638eb278058fc/WFS/WFS_plot_in_Cartopy.ipynb

jcothran commented 10 years ago

@rsignell-usgs I don't have WFS enabled for this ESRI server we manage at the moment I believe, an example layer feature query using the REST format is below. Like that the Cat-Interop servicetype listing recognizes various service types that might be more commonly in-use although not necessarily formally registered with the OGC or other standards bodies that I'm aware of at the moment.

@emiliom I'm on the same track as you there, hoping to see the Cat-Interop servicetype table listing recognized by the NGDC or other main catalogs, which would include www:link and maybe add something like ESRI:Rest ? if that is not already covered in the other ESRI services?

http://gsaaportal.org/proxy/rest_query/?url=http%3A%2F%2F129.252.139.110%2Fgsaa%2Frest%2Fservices%2FSCDNR%2FMapServer%2F24%2Fquery%3Fgeometry%3D-8994098.2628326%252C3338701.6112945%252C-8979422.3534039%252C3324025.7018658%26geometryType%3DesriGeometryEnvelope%26inSR%3D102113%26outSR%3D102113%26spatialRel%3DesriSpatialRelIntersects%26f%3Djson%26returnGeometry%3Dtrue%26outFields%3DDATE_%252COBSERVER%252COBSMODE%252CCOUNTY%252CCONUM%252CLONGDM%252CLATDM%252CTOWNSHIP%252CRANGE%252CSECTION%252CGAZPAGE%252CERA%252CNEW90%252CSTATUS90%252CSTATUS80%252CSTATUS70%252CSUBSTRAT%252CCANOPY%252CLOCATION%252CISLAND%252CSIZE_%252CSIZECONF%252CSPECCONF%252CBRPE%252CDCCO%252CANHI%252CGBHE%252CGWHE%252CGREG%252CSNEG%252CLBHE%252CTCHE%252CREEG%252CCAEG%252CGRHE%252CBCNH%252CYCNH%252CWHIB%252CGLIB%252CROSP%252CWOST%252CSMWT%252CLGWT%252CSMDK%252CLGDK