Content warnings for video

iptc / video-metadata-hub

Specification and examples for IPTC's Video Metadata Hub

MIT License

2 stars 0 forks source link

Content warnings for video #3

Closed bquinn closed 1 year ago

bquinn commented 3 years ago

Examples of warnings, from a fairly random site https://www.kapwing.com/resources/use-this-free-template-to-add-a-content-warning-to-any-video/:

Violence, blood, or graphic images
Bright, fast flashes and colors for people who suffer from photosensitive epilepsy.
Dizzying movements that may be disorienting or nauseating. These may be uncomfortable for individuals with certain types of vertigo.
Curse words, hate speech, or explicit language
Nudity or sexuality
Drug use and narcotics
Triggers: Language or imagery that may cause a traumatized person to relive a past experience, especially related to self-harm, sexual assault, or suicide.

Here's what Netflix say about theirs, for users: https://help.netflix.com/en/node/2064

For "partners": https://partnerhelp.netflixstudios.com/hc/en-us/articles/360057622133-Photosensitive-Epilepsy-Guidelines-What-Can-I-Do-If-My-Content-Fails-

bquinn commented 2 years ago

Can the PII issue #12 fit with this one?

bquinn commented 2 years ago

We have an existing CV for the purpose of content warnings: https://cv.iptc.org/newscodes/contentwarning/ maybe we should review the list?

bquinn commented 2 years ago

Derek looked up the terms that they have in his system at Getty:

Death
Graphic Content
Nudity
Profanity
Suggestive Content

Another term that has been suggested is "Traumatic" or "Disturbing" content.

bquinn commented 2 years ago

We found the MDDF list of national/territory ratings systems: https://www.movielabs.com/md/ratings/v2.4.8/html/Summary.html

It looks like we need a field to store one or more national/territory ratings, used for compliance, and separately to track warnings based on the content itself.

bquinn commented 2 years ago

For territory ratings, we have #21, so let's focus on content warnings.

For the field, how about the following:

Property Group	Property Name	Definition / Semantics	User Notes	Change Notes	Basic Type/Cardinality	EBUcore Property	XMP Property
administrative	Content Warning	Information to warn potential viewers about nudity, violence etc in the video	Recommended CV: https://cv.iptc.org/newscodes/contentwarning/	New 1.4	CV Term structure (0..unbounded)	n/a	Iptc4xmpExt:ContentWarning

For the CV, here's what we have in our CV vs other systems:

IPTC contentwarning CV	Getty	BBC [source]
Death	Death	Violence
Language	Profanity	Language
Nudity	Nudity	Sex/Nudity
Sexuality	Suggestive Content	Sex/Nudity
Suffering	Graphic Content	Upsetting or disturbing content
Violence	Graphic Content	Violence
		Adult Humour / Adult Themes
		Drugs / Imitation / Medical scenes
		RFI - Flashing Images

So perhaps we should add drugs and flashing images. Do we need "adult humour"?

bquinn commented 1 year ago

Resolved with the release of VMHub v1.4