search

irtf-nwcrg / draft-irtf-nwcrg-network-coding-satellites

Network coding and satellites
0 stars 1 forks source link

Comments on DTN #13

Closed NicoKos closed 5 years ago

NicoKos commented 5 years ago

legitimate -> legitimize.

This entire section is unnecessary. With this draft on a multi-gateway satellite system and DVB, you're talking about geostationary satellites which are always visible. Little disruption. 600ms or so delay is coped with by Internet protocols (RFC829 SATNET work etc.) So, not a significant delay issue either. It's out of scope for the abstract. And geostationary satellites generally don't use CCSDS for broadband; TDRSS is so much a special case. Since we're not standards track, References aren't split informative/normative -- but given the DVB starting point, I'd expect to see more DVB-S references. EN 302 307, which details extensions of the original satellite transmission standard DVB-S (EN 300 421), etc.

elochin commented 5 years ago

We need to discuss this point. Just corrected legitimize in #22