search

isa-camss / CAV

The Core Assessment Vocabulary represents and defines what an “Assessment” of “assets” is and how to perform the assessment based on “Criteria”. It is a domain-agnostic vocabulary, meaning that it can be used to assess any type of assets.
3 stars 1 forks source link

Assessment concept #15

Open giorgialodi opened 3 years ago

giorgialodi commented 3 years ago

The assessment concept is defined as an intellectual work and it is a dataset. However, looking at some of its properties (e.g., triggers, performedBy) it seems more related to an event (there are properties from assessment to assessment for instance that are actually defined as event) or an activity performed by some agent. I am getting a little bit lot here in understanding this concept: do you mean the activity that is performed by or requested by an agent and that produces an "assessment result" (that is the intellectual work) or with assessment do you mean the final result of the assessment (probably it is then more appropriate to use created by an agent: and these properties are BTW already included in DCAT-AP for the dataset)? This concept is crucial and understanding it it is strategic for the overall model. Pay attention that from a foundational point of view the concepts here are disjoint: if it is an event, it is not an object (as it could be considered a dataset).

jseguraf commented 3 years ago

See also issue #4

jseguraf commented 3 years ago

Decision: the definition of assessment will be perfected to include the idea that an assessment is a work, not necessary finished that includes many aspects such as who do the intelllectual work, what was the work consists of, why, how the work relates to other assessments, etc.

jseguraf commented 3 years ago

The solution to this issue (i.e. enriching/connecting with Provenance, Authoring, and Versioning) needs that issue #5 is solved before hand.