List item prefixes are counted as words

isaaclyman / novel-word-count-obsidian

Obsidian plugin. Displays a word count or other statistic for each file, folder and vault in the File Explorer pane.

https://obsidian.md/plugins?id=novel-word-count

MIT License

85 stars 8 forks source link

List item prefixes are counted as words #62

Closed redactedscribe closed 1 year ago

redactedscribe commented 1 year ago

Description

7 words:

- 1
- 2
- 3
-

Same goes for *- and +-prefixed lists. The core plugin "Word count" also has this issue, but only for --prefixed lists (which will hopefully be fixed).

Device

Windows.

I originally posted this here by accident. I was attempting to see why word counts were not the same and got the repos confused.

Thanks.

Edit: Apparently this is a known special case.

isaaclyman commented 1 year ago

Novel Word Count defines a "word" as any sequence of one or more non-whitespace characters.

I'm reluctant to change this for a few reasons:

People have differing opinions of what should be considered a word.
Software has differing opinions of what should be considered a word. If you're writing in Obsidian with the intent to paste your content into another app or a form, it would be detrimental to exclude things (especially things visible in Reading Mode) that the other software would include.
NWC's performance has been tuned and re-tuned and at present is pretty fast (can count 4.8 million words in less than a second on my MacBook Air). If I go down the path of letting people fight out more and more specific inclusions and exclusions to the "word" regex, performance will degrade, especially on large vaults.

I'm closing this for now, but if more users start requesting it, I can reconsider.

isaaclyman commented 9 months ago

@redactedscribe This should be fixed now (v3.4.0).

redactedscribe commented 9 months ago

Nice! Seems to work, thanks.