search

itp-dwd / 2020-spring

Repo for Dynamic Web Development Spring, 2020
26 stars 18 forks source link

[meta] How to give feedback #19

Closed joeyklee closed 4 years ago

joeyklee commented 4 years ago

I love this piece about "How to talk to kids" as a way of deconstructing feedback, suggestions, advice, and critique. Regardless of whether we're talking to children or adults, this type of conscientiousness is amazing.

https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/mr-rogers-neighborhood-talking-to-kids/562352/

catarak commented 4 years ago

I love this! Here's some other stuff I've pulled together (in ICM, but wasn't quite sure how to use it):

Giving Criticism

A short guide for offering constructive criticism, pulled from Golan Levin and Tega Brain's forthcoming book, Code as Creative Medium: A Teacher's Manual:

  1. Description: What do you see?
  2. Analysis: How is it made? What does it make you think about or feel?
  3. Interpretation: What is it about? What is the main idea being explored?
  4. Evaluation: Is it successful? Does it explore the prompt in a compelling, interesting or unique way?

Receiving Criticism

Receiving criticism is a skill to develop alongside giving criticism. We are all giving time and energy to help each other with our work, so how can you receive critical feedback as generosity? How can you separate you, as an individual, and your identity from your work?

It's also an important skill to be able to sort what is useful for you and what is not. It can sometimes be hard and triggering to receive criticism, and that's something to be mindful of as well. Here are some "rules of the road" for receiving criticism, adapted from The Artist's Way by Julia Cameron.

  1. Receive the criticism all the way through and get it over with.
  2. Jot down notes to yourself on what concepts or phrases bother you.
  3. Jot down notes on what concepts or phrases seem useful.
  4. Do something very nuturing for yourself—read an old good review or recall a compliment.
  5. Remember that even if you have made a truly rotten piece of art, it may be necessary stepping-stone to your next work. Art matures spasmodically and requires ugly-ducking growth stages.
  6. Look at the criticism again. Does it remind of you any criticism from your past?
  7. Write a letter to the critic—not to be mailed, most probably. Defend your work and acknowledge what was helpful, if anything, in the criticism proffered.
  8. Get back on the horse. Make an immediate commitment to do something creative.
  9. Do it. Creativity is the only cure for criticism.
joeyklee commented 4 years ago

Added this also to the wiki: https://github.com/itp-dwd/2020-spring/wiki/How-to:-Feedback

Let's close this issue when ready! We can update/add refs to the wiki?

joeyklee commented 4 years ago

Closing this now!