itsmejr257 / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

sellstock keeps stock from previous instance #7

Open itsmejr257 opened 4 months ago

itsmejr257 commented 4 months ago

From the previous game, i added a single BYD stock which i did not sell. After losing, i started a new game but was still able to sell this stock. Is the stocks bought in the previous game intended to stay till the next game?

image.png

Classified this bug as a medium as it does not affect the use of other features in the application. However, this may potentially be of a high severity given that the user wont be able to accurately play the game.

nus-se-script commented 4 months ago

Team's Response

Good point, but our team consider stock as an asset that cost a lot of money so it would stay with the user all the time as long as it is not sold. But this is indeed not a very wise implementation.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue severity

Team chose [severity.Low] Originally [severity.Medium]

Reason for disagreement: Thank you for clarifying. However, I strongly believe that this should be a medium instead of a low. Given that this flaw/feature was not specifically stated in the userguide or the application, I do not believe that this flaw would only happen in very rare situations as buying stock is a part of the game. In this case, it causes an occasional inconvenience to the user who wants to “accurately” play the game, as they would be wondering why they have stocks even though they started a new game. Hence, the only way the user would be able to find out that this is an *intended feature, is to report it as a question/issue.