msdemlei
commented
9 months ago On Fri, Nov 24, 2023 at 10:45:13AM -0800, Tom wrote:
As this appendix was somewhat speculative, perhaps it could be reduce to listing common patterns that have evolved with VOTable, or indeed removed entirely. For parts that are still considered
If you ask me: Let's just remove it. It's been a constant source of confusion. Also, we now have Notes established, so if folks want to present clever (if non-normative) ways to use VOTable, that's where they can do it.
mbtaylor
tomdonaldson
Bonnarel
As mentioned in #51, Appendix A ("Possible VOTable extensions") has a number of things that are not consistent with the current state of VOTable, other standards or intended uses.
As this appendix was somewhat speculative, perhaps it could be reduce to listing common patterns that have evolved with VOTable, or indeed removed entirely. For parts that are still considered valuable, we should certainly update the examples to be compliant with current standards and guidance.