inputs of the ConvLSTMCell

[anxingle]

I have some confusions about the code:

1. _conv(args, output_size, ....) which say shape of inputs is (batch_size x height x width x arg_size) , what's the meaning of "arg_size"?

2. How to define the input of COnvLSTMCell ? I know how to define a network of LSTM:

     X = tf.placeholder([batch_size,time_steps,dim_input])             
     # [batchsize, time_steps, diminput] => [nsteps, batchsize, dim_input]
     X = tf.transpose(X, [1, 0, 2])
     # 2. Reshape input to [nsteps*batchsize, dim_input]
     X = tf.reshape( X, [-1, dim_input])
     # 3. Input layer => Hidden layer
     input_split = tf.matmul(X, _W['hidden']) + _b['hidden']
     # 4. Splite data to 'nsteps' chunks. An i-th chunck indicates i-th batch data
     input_split = tf.split(0,time_steps, input_split)
     lstm_cell = tf.nn.rnn_cell.BasicLSTMCell(num_hidden, \
                                        forget_bias=1.0,state_is_tuple=True)
     lstm_cell = tf.nn.rnn_cell.MultiRNNCell([lstm_cell]*num_layers,\
                                        state_is_tuple=True)
     state     = lstm_cell.zero_state(batch_size,dtype=tf.float32)
     LSTM_O, LSTM_S = tf.nn.rnn(lstm_cell, input_split, \
                                        initial_state=state)

   In the above code ,how to chang the X and input_split to feed to ConvLSTMCell ? (A simple demo which show us how to use would more grateful ! )

[iwyoo]

Sorry for missing the example code. I now add an example code in README.md that I used before.

1. Usually, input of convolution layer has 4-dimension, [batch, height, width, channel]. arg_size is channel size. (An example of channel is RGB.)
2. Please read my code in README.md. The input shape of each cell is [batch, height, width, channel].

I'll left this issue open, if you have any question more, then comment it. If not, close this issue. Thank you!

[anxingle]

@iwyoo Thanks a million!

[anxingle]

     x = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, [batch_size, height, width, nsteps, channel])
     _Hsplit = tf.split(3, _nsteps, _X)
     #shape: step_size *[None,height,width,channel]
     _Hsplit = [tf.squeeze(p_input,[3]) for p_input in _Hsplit]
     with tf.variable_scope(_name):
         lstm_cell = convLSTM(dimhidden,forget_bias=1.0,\
                           state_is_tuple=True)
        #lstm_cell = tf.nn.rnn_cell.DropoutWrapper(lstm_cell, input_keep_prob=0.5,\
        #                 output_keep_prob=0.5)
        state     = lstm_cell.zero_state(batch_size,height,width)
        #lstm_cell = tf.nn.rnn_cell.MultiRNNCell([lstm_cell]*num_layers,\
        #                                state_is_tuple=True)
        outputs = []
        for input_ in _Hsplit:
            output,state = lstm_cell(input_,state)
            outputs.append(output)
        result_out = []
        state_h     = lstm_cell.zero_state(batch_size,height,width)
        for output_ in outputs:
            out,state_h  = lstm_cell(output_,state_h)
            result_out.append(out)
        #_LSTM_O, _LSTM_S = tf.nn.rnn(lstm_cell, _Hsplit, \
        #                                initial_state=state)
        return result_out

I cann't use "DropoutWrapper" and "MultiRNNCell" and "tf.nn.rnn". So I rewrite the same functions to replace the "tf.nn.rnn" . But I got that :
File "lstm_ctc_ori.py", line 84, in _RNN output,state = lstmcell(input,state) File "/mnt/d/workspace/ubuntu/experiment_recog/convLstm/ConvLSTMCell.py", line 70, in call c, h = state File "/mnt/d/workspace/ubuntu/tf/local/lib/python2.7/site-packages/tensorflow/python/framework/ops.py", line 495, in iter raise TypeError("'Tensor' object is not iterable.") TypeError: 'Tensor' object is not iterable. I want to feed to the network pictures like this:

[iwyoo]

I have not checked that existing implementations are compatible with those provided by TensorFlow because they use different operators. I will try to implement it as soon as I can. The layers mentioned above (DropoutWrapper, MultiRNNCell, tf.nn.rnn) can be stacked directly as a block using ConvLSTMCell. If you are in a hurry, I suggest you implement it in such a way. (I've done similar experiments in the past.) When I read the contents of the error, it seems to be caused by the difference between the past version and the current version. (With is_state_stuple variable) I am going to implement it by referring to the current Tensorflow version implementation. But I can not confirm how long it will take.

[anxingle]

Ok. I will try to implement it and your implementation of the ConvLSTM do give me a lot help. Thank you .

[rogertrullo]

Hi @iwyoo , thanks for sharing your implementation! In the example provided in the README, it is written this: t_output, state = cell(p_input_, state, k_size) I think the k_size parameter, should be actually the scope name. Shouldn't it?

[iwyoo]

Oh, thanks for noticing me. The README file was the old version. Now, it is fixed.