ixmilia / dxf

MIT License
218 stars 67 forks source link

Opening file error "Not a valid DXF file header: `?0`" #196

Closed Siro2002 closed 1 year ago

Siro2002 commented 1 year ago

While i'm opening a dxf file with enconding code 65001 -> exception " Not a valid DXF file header: ?0 "

at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfTextReader.GetCodePair() in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfTextReader.cs:line 158 at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfTextReader.d__5.MoveNext() in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfTextReader.cs:line 27 at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfBufferReader`1.Advance() in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfCodePairBufferReader.cs:line 33 at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfCodePairBufferReader..ctor(IDxfCodePairReader reader) in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfCodePairBufferReader.cs:line 48 at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfFile.LoadFromReader(IDxfCodePairReader reader) in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfFile.cs:line 267 at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfFile.Load(Stream stream, Encoding defaultEncoding) in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfFile.cs:line 213 at IxMilia.Dxf.DxfFile.Load(String path, Encoding defaultEncoding) in D:\a\dxf\dxf\src\IxMilia.Dxf\DxfFile.cs:line 184

The same file with encoding 1251 -> no problem, correct visualization

brettfo commented 1 year ago

Presumably you passed in the appropriate encoding to DxfFile.Load()? Can you share the 65001 encoded file with me so I can look into it? You can either upload/attach the file to this issue, or if you want it to remain private, you can email it directly to me at brett.forsgren@outlook.com and I'll make sure the file doesn't get out and I'll delete it when I'm done.

Siro2002 commented 1 year ago

Presumably you passed in the appropriate encoding to DxfFile.Load()? Can you share the 65001 encoded file with me so I can look into it? You can either upload/attach the file to this issue, or if you want it to remain private, you can email it directly to me at brett.forsgren@outlook.com and I'll make sure the file doesn't get out and I'll delete it when I'm done.

I attach 2 files, the same piece exported, but with two different encoding code (the name of the file) Thank you very much Encoding.zip

brettfo commented 1 year ago

Thank you for filing the issue and attaching the drawings! The code that trims off the byte order mark wasn't fully complete so there was a stray 0xFEFF at the start of the file. I've updated main with the fix.

Siro2002 commented 1 year ago

Hi, thank you for your fix, but i'm using ixmilia as a nuget packet in Visual Studio and i see only version 0.8.3. Can you make a release? Currently, I can't open dxf files. Thank you very much!

brettfo commented 1 year ago

I'd be happy to do another NuGet release, but I want to be sure I've fixed your issue. Could you try building this repo locally and directly referencing the project/assembly to see if it works? If you have .NET 7 installed, you can simply run build-and-test.cmd (or build-and-test.sh if on Linux/Mac) and after that you can add a project reference in your solution.

Siro2002 commented 1 year ago

I tried your code and it seems to work fine. I had to change a line of code in the "DxfFile.cs" file because otherwise it would tell me "file not found". Can you please check? I used the file I gave you last time and Dxffile.load works fine.

my changes have been:

    public static DxfFile Load(Stream stream, Encoding defaultEncoding)
    {
        int readBytes;
        var firstLine = GetFirstLine(stream, defaultEncoding, out readBytes);
        var reader = new BinaryReader(stream);

        // check for binary sentinels
        DxfFile file;
        if (firstLine == DxbReader.BinarySentinel)
        {
            file = new DxbReader().ReadFile(reader);
        }
        else
        {

//var dxfReader = GetCodePairReader(firstLine, readBytes, reader, defaultEncoding); -> not works file = LoadFromReader(new DxfTextReader(reader.BaseStream, defaultEncoding, firstLine)); }

        return file;
    }

if you think everything is ok, that's fine with me. so i can use nuget package Thank you very much

Siro2002 commented 1 year ago

Any news?

brettfo commented 1 year ago

@Siro2002 I'm unclear on your second-to-last comment where I asked you to verify if the current state of main worked for your scenario. You responded with:

I tried your code and it seems to work fine. I had to change a line of code...

Did you have to make any changes to the current state of main to get your scenario to work? If not, I'm happy to push an updated package to NuGet, but if any changes are required, I'd need to make those before I hit publish.

Siro2002 commented 1 year ago

@Siro2002 I'm unclear on your second-to-last comment where I asked you to verify if the current state of main worked for your scenario. You responded with:

I tried your code and it seems to work fine. I had to change a line of code...

Did you have to make any changes to the current state of main to get your scenario to work? If not, I'm happy to push an updated package to NuGet, but if any changes are required, I'd need to make those before I hit publish.

This line var dxfReader = GetCodePairReader(firstLine, readBytes, reader, defaultEncoding); in function public static DxfFile Load(Stream stream, Encoding defaultEncoding)

Please check because if I remove that line my scenario will works, otherwise I have a crash in that point. Please check if it is important for other reasons, if not you can make a release. Thank you