search

j-hc / zygisk-detach

Zygisk module to detach installed apps from Play Store, hooking binder
https://t.me/rv_magisk
Apache License 2.0
1.07k stars 30 forks source link

Play Store Crash #21

Closed squishey123 closed 7 months ago

squishey123 commented 9 months ago

Oneplus 11 Android 14 LiniageOS 21 21-20231107-UNOFFICIAL-salami

Screenshot of Play Store page of the app you are trying to detach:

Unable to provide screenshot due to play store crashing

Screenshot of the helper CLI showing detached apps (from Option 2):

Screenshot_20240102-012029_Termux.png

Logs taken with su -c logcat -d -s "zygisk-detach" > /sdcard/log.txt:

log.txt

Not providing this information will get your issue closed

Upon enabling the magisk package and doing a restart, the play store will crash within a second or two. If I try to interact with anything it crashes immediately. I have tried wiping the Google play store data as well as Google play services. No change.

j-hc commented 9 months ago
  1. did you make sure disabling zygisk-detach fixes the crashes?
  2. i need the full log (logcat -d > /sdcard/log) just after crashing
squishey123 commented 9 months ago
  1. did you make sure disabling zygisk-detach fixes the crashes?
  2. i need the full log (logcat -d > /sdcard/log) just after crashing

  1. Yes, disabling zygisk-detach stops the crashing. Just tested it now to make sure.

  2. log.txt

squishey123 commented 9 months ago

I think something may have happened to Google play services or one of the gapps in the switch from mindetach to zygisk-detach so I'll also try re-sideloading that today and see if that helps anything.

j-hc commented 9 months ago
  1. did you make sure disabling zygisk-detach fixes the crashes?
  2. i need the full log (logcat -d > /sdcard/log) just after crashing

  1. Yes, disabling zygisk-detach stops the crashing. Just tested it now to make sure.

  2. log.txt

these logs does not contain any crash. you can either use termux with su or give permission to the app you are using for getting the logcat.

squishey123 commented 9 months ago
  1. did you make sure disabling zygisk-detach fixes the crashes?
  2. i need the full log (logcat -d > /sdcard/log) just after crashing

  1. Yes, disabling zygisk-detach stops the crashing. Just tested it now to make sure.

  2. log.txt

these logs does not contain any crash. you can either use termux with su or give permission to the app you are using for getting the logcat.

I guess I'm not really sure what you would classify this as because maybe it's not a traditional crash?

Screen capture below, app opens fine but once you try to open a menu then it just closes

https://github.com/j-hc/zygisk-detach/assets/16481004/aba77b4c-9f59-4adf-bbf0-d50d84145058

j-hc commented 9 months ago

its not about the "type of crash". you didnt get the log properly. execute this in termux right after the crash: su -c logcat -d > /sdcard/log.txt

squishey123 commented 9 months ago

its not about the "type of crash". you didnt get the log properly. execute this in termux right after the crash: su -c logcat -d > /sdcard/log.txt

How does this look? log.txt

j-hc commented 9 months ago

what are the other modules you are using? and are you using a fork of magisk?

StrayJoker commented 9 months ago

try Shamiko module and umount for gms、play store

squishey123 commented 9 months ago

what are the other modules you are using? and are you using a fork of magisk?

Screenshot below of my installed modules, I also just did a fresh install of the latest build of liniageOS and mind the gapps to rule out Google play services being the issue. No it is not a fork, from the official github repo.

Screenshot_20240104-124644_Magisk.png

j-hc commented 9 months ago

what are the other modules you are using? and are you using a fork of magisk?

Screenshot below of my installed modules, I also just did a fresh install of the latest build of liniageOS and mind the gapps to rule out Google play services being the issue. No it is not a fork, from the official github repo.

Screenshot_20240104-124644_Magisk.png

can you try disabling other modules and test only with zygisk-detach enabled? it is not immediately obvious what causes the crash in the logs

squishey123 commented 9 months ago

what are the other modules you are using? and are you using a fork of magisk?

Screenshot below of my installed modules, I also just did a fresh install of the latest build of liniageOS and mind the gapps to rule out Google play services being the issue. No it is not a fork, from the official github repo.

Screenshot_20240104-124644_Magisk.png

can you try disabling other modules and test only with zygisk-detach enabled? it is not immediately obvious what causes the crash in the logs

I found the problem child. The only one of the packages that seems to cause the problem while zygisk-detach is enabled is pixelify https://github.com/Kingsman44/Pixelify

squishey123 commented 8 months ago

Have not gotten anywhere with this but updating with a link to the open issue

https://github.com/Kingsman44/Pixelify/issues/278

j-hc commented 7 months ago

im closing the issue as this is not something i could fix. could even be a play store bug i dont know.