Problem with saving ID3v2.4.0 tags

OliverSeegatz commented 9 years ago

I have some mp3 files that have id3v2.4.0 tags and id3v1.1 tags. I use kid3 for writing the tags. When I try to make a change to the lyrics of an mp3 in jajuk and save it all id3v2.4.0 tags in this file are empty, only the id3v1.1 tags remain in the file. In jajuk I can still see all entries of this file. With mp3 files with id3v2.3.0 tags this effect does not occur. My operating systems are Ubuntu 14.4 and LinuxMint 17.

bflorat commented 9 years ago

To be investigated... note that jajuk uses jaudiotagger 2.2.0. We need to reproduce this and, if necessary, forward this issue to jaudiotagger project.

gkerdal commented 9 years ago

I'm trying to reproduce the problem on Ubuntu 14.10 with kid3. My test : I have a mp3 file with both information id3v2.4.0 and id3v1.1, from Jajuk I can only see id3v2.4.0. When I change the title from Jajuk and reopen the file in kid3 I see the change in the id3v2.4 part.

If I change the title id3v2.4 in kid3 and I refresh Jajuk, I see the new title in jajuk
If I change the title id3v1.1 in kid3 and I refresh Jajuk, I don't see the title in jajuk but it seems to be a normal behaviour to me since id3v2.4 > id3v1.1.

Could you post the full test and maybe a screenshot ?

jajuk-team / jajuk

Problem with saving ID3v2.4.0 tags #1983