search

jakartaee / jakartaee-api

jakartaee-api
Other
39 stars 42 forks source link

Published Jakarta EE 8 BOM misses jakarta.xml.bind-api and jakarta.xml.ws-api #136

Open bogdandrutu opened 1 year ago

bogdandrutu commented 1 year ago

This issue was fixed in https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-api/pull/56, but not ported to 8.0.0 BOM.

scottkurz commented 1 year ago

Noting that the discussion in https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-api/issues/97 seemed to assume that all the right changes had been made in 8.0.x-BRANCH, and the only thing needed was to publish a release.

But this issue suggests that some of the other additions in #56 need to be merged into the 8.0.x BOM as well. E.g. the jakarta.xml.bind-api dependency is already included in https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-api/blob/8.0.x-BRANCH/jakartaee-bom/pom.xml but the jakarta.xml.ws-api is not.

I haven't personally reviewed what the contents of the 8.0.x BOM should be but hopefully it was helpful for me to capture that summary.

I know @ivargrimstad had attempted to do a release but hit a problem with the build infrastructure, so mentioning him for when he has a chance to look here.

bogdandrutu commented 1 year ago

@scottkurz you are correct, we should also add jakarta.xml.ws-api to the bom. My rule of thumb is that we should add all artifacts that the repo produces in the bom.

ko-at-work commented 9 months ago

@scottkurz @bogdandrutu If one were to backport the changes in https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-api/pull/56 applicable to 8.0.x, would that give some impetus to release 8.0.1 to resolve https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-api/issues/97 and and https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-api/issues/136 (this issue)? I am curious whether it would be wasted time if no one is committed to a 8.0.1 release.

scottkurz commented 9 months ago

@scottkurz @bogdandrutu If one were to backport the changes in #56 applicable to 8.0.x, would that give some impetus to release 8.0.1 to resolve #97 and and #136 (this issue)? I am curious whether it would be wasted time if no one is committed to a 8.0.1 release.

@ivargrimstad do you have a sense of if/when you might make another attempt at an 8.0.x update release? It's possible we might see another PR proposal to build into it here. Thanks.

ivargrimstad commented 9 months ago

@ivargrimstad do you have a sense of if/when you might make another attempt at an 8.0.x update release? It's possible we might see another PR proposal to build into it here. Thanks.

I don't have any plans for pursuing this at the moment. Any committer on the Platform Project can take the initiative to get it done. You may bring it up on the next platform call to gauge interest. If anyone wants to look at the job and see if they can get it to work, feel free to give it a try. https://ci.eclipse.org/jakartaee-platform/job/ONLY_FOR_EE8-StagingRelease/