Wave discussion: Refresh JakartaEE11ReleasePlan.md with a view toward getting it beyond DRAFT

[edburns]

Consider https://github.com/jakartaee/jakartaee-platform/blob/gh-pages/jakartaee11/JakartaEE11ReleasePlan.md

The Waves section needs to be refreshed to keep in mind the following concerns.

1. Pragmatic: getting it done
2. Latest dependency analysis @janwesterkamp-ijug
3. Lowest priority, not universally accepted as necessary, but worth exploring: ability to combine related specs into one:
   • XML web services specs
   • JSON specs
   • Security specs
   • CDI related specs

[JanWesterkamp-iJUG]

Update on the jQA dependency analysis:

This is a follow up from the old ticket created to support the Jakarta EE 10 Release.

The project to analyse Jakata EE is maintained here and was updated recently to use the new maven plugin versions. I will update the configuration options in the POM file soon...

Here the results (created with the former version) for Jakarta EE and it's profiles with Maven Central as the source:

20230512 01.zip

The reports can be found in the jqassistant/report folder subdirectories, interesing might be especially:

• plantuml (generated PlantUML source and rendered SVG, the SpecificationDependencyDiagram varriant shows the dependency versions combined)
• csv (generated CSV files with the versions per dependency in table form)

Unfortunately I can not upload the SVGs here to show them directly, because GitHub modifies them then (!)

[JanWesterkamp-iJUG]

There is also a edited version of the diagrams for a potential 10.0.1 Service/Patch release showing some issues and fixed things:

20230515 01.zip

This can be helpful to check the waves.

[JanWesterkamp-iJUG]

The (current) result for API dependencies (only):

Wave 1:

• Jakarta Activation
• Jakarta Annotation*
• Jakarta Authentication
• Jakarta EJB
• Jakarta EL
• Jakarta Lang Model
• Jakarta Inject
• Jakarta JSON
• Jakarta Persistence
• Jakarta Security
• Jakarta Servlet
• Jakarta Validation
• Jakarta REST
• Jakarta Websocket Client

Wave 2:

• Jakarta Authorization
• Jakarta Interceptor*
• Jakarta JMS
• Jakarta JSON Bind
• Jakarta Mail
• Jakarta Servlet JSP
• Jakarta Websocket
• Jakarta XMP Bind
• Jakarta XML SOAP

Wave 3:

• Jakarta CDI*
• Jakarta Servlet JSP JSTL
• Jakarta XML WS

Wave 4:

• Jakarta Batch
• Jakarta Concurrent
• Jakarta Transaction*
• Jakarta Platform Core Profile

Wave 5:

• Jakarta Faces*
• Jakarta Ressource

Wave 6:

• Jakarta Platform Web Profile*

Wave 7:

• Jakarta Platform*

*critical path

@edburns and @arjantijms: I hope this first review of the waves is helpful?

[edburns]

THanks, @JanWesterkamp-iJUG , this is a great way to keep the progress going. We'll continue this in #685 .

[JanWesterkamp-iJUG]

@edburns, a little follow up:

To fix the issues in the newest jQA version 2.0 I created these issues:

• https://github.com/jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies/issues/9
• https://github.com/jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies/issues/10
• https://github.com/jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies/issues/8

But version 1.2 can still be used meanwhile.

[DirkMahler]

@edburns, a little follow up:

To fix the issues in the newest jQA version 2.0 I created these issues:

* [jQA 2.0 does not run with Java SE 17 jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies#9](https://github.com/jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies/issues/9)

* [GraphML report plugin is missing jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies#10](https://github.com/jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies/issues/10)

* [The ELK rendering creates an issue that prevents diagram rendering jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies#8](https://github.com/jqassistant-demo/jakarta-ee-dependencies/issues/8)

But version 1.2 can still be used meanwhile.

The issues with jQA 2.0 should be fixed now, sorry for the inconvenience.