j.ramp: List ramping does not work with varying number of list members

lossius commented 9 years ago

In the below patch:

At the left side j.ramp is first set to a single float value. next it is requested to ramp as a list. Result: Nothing happens
At the right side it is set to a list of same length as subsequent list. Result: Works as expected.

@theod - Do you have any idea if this is a bug in he max external or if it rather is a Core-related bug?


----------begin_max5_patcher----------
426.3ocwUE0aBBCD9Y3WQSelQZQPw8WYwrTkKZMXgzVbZL9eevAD0M00YXtW
Zyc8528cebG8fuGcdwNvPIuRdi34cv2yCc03vqy1itQraQtvfgQ2.FiXIPCZ
OqTCFPYEVYg5cMrv1hURZTHKfDkD2rw5VHy5tkpZiTkCVDxnNmF69b.yA8TX
EU19338oTXWrRpVdszga73onUzYYTlgHWLe8Ki6guEa69RnEEJkLq4ji99MK
AOlhXgcHqnrv5ZtlMgjnPhVrojjvXL2DNdL6YJb7Qo3VTx8DtICrvofOpg8a
515vFwxQcZ5jeVm3NpSQ+rNMEEn336ISo2VlBFndrgtMHJYh6yOIOs4maN77
GU+8iAb98p+Q+GiACcCceE6RCM+WzPi2mlKUe8UEjCM9uTILEU5E8v08SFxI
VjAFqTgC+mES5EwrRlkA3wr9aIMh44.VArq9EwU1j5.apeOgveJrg6.aRdZr
YjCrg+feoZaiDkkaAsoCRjH0iNqKzMlSBPSop0DQjpgsx93GidD55Veaceek
tcTY23XZ6UKx.spRhST9MY9n+mvXowfY
-----------end_max5_patcher-----------

theod commented 8 years ago

it is in TTRamp.cpp at line 301 :

    if (mNumValues == inputValue.size())

I can take care of it but it is strange for me to allow such kind of feature...

theod commented 8 years ago

I mean it will need to make complex code where it would be easier to prevent the user that he is doing something wrong. don't you think ?

theod commented 8 years ago

as I said before it seems to me this issue is not relevant. should we close it ?

lossius commented 8 years ago

Yes, we can close it.

jamoma / JamomaMax

j.ramp: List ramping does not work with varying number of list members #935