janishar / android-mvvm-architecture

This repository contains a detailed sample app that implements MVVM architecture using Dagger2, Room, RxJava2, FastAndroidNetworking and PlaceholderView
https://janisharali.com
Apache License 2.0
2.96k stars 934 forks source link

Caution: A ViewModel must never reference a view, Lifecycle, or any class that may hold a reference to the activity context. #65

Open ameybhandarkar opened 5 years ago

ameybhandarkar commented 5 years ago

https://github.com/MindorksOpenSource/android-mvvm-architecture/blob/595acd0c79a4a7a51594cbc88071f85f266f26ff/app/src/main/java/com/mindorks/framework/mvvm/ui/login/LoginActivity.java#L91

ameybhandarkar commented 5 years ago

I am trying to implement MVVM in my current project. I was searching for some references. I just to clear a few doubts. So you can correct me if I am wrong.

mLoginViewModel.setNavigator(this);

This line of code is actually passing on the reference of the current activity to that viewmodel. But as per documentation, Caution: A ViewModel must never reference a view, Lifecycle, or any class that may hold a reference to the activity context. So is there any alternative to this?

I am also searching for an approach of handling errors thrown by the API. I'd be glad if you can guide me through. Thanks

clj0020 commented 5 years ago

@ameybhandarkar the navigator is an interface between the activity and the viewmodel. That is not holding a reference to a context or really anything. There is a special kind of viewmodel called the AndroidViewModel that does hold reference to a context.

ArthurSav commented 5 years ago

@clj0020 It holds a reference to the object that implements the interface, in this case the activity. There are better ways to notify the UI, try using Live Data.

nguyenvanminhfptpoly commented 4 years ago

@ameybhandarkar have idea for replace Weak references

in ViewModel i create /////////////////////////////// data class Input( val name: Observable<String>, val image: Observable<ByteArray>, val triggerAdd: Observable<Unit> ) data class Output( val isAdd: Observable<Boolean> )

fun transform(input: Input): Output{
    val nameImage = BehaviorSubject.create<String>()
    val imageLibrary = BehaviorSubject.create<ByteArray>()
    val isAdd = BehaviorSubject.create<Boolean>()

    with(input){
        name.subscribe(nameImage)
        image.subscribe(imageLibrary)
        triggerAdd.subscribe {
            val name = nameImage.value ?:""
            val image = imageLibrary.value ?: byteArrayOf()
            dataManager.insert(Library(null,name,image))
                .subscribeOn(schedulerProvider.io)
                .observeOn(schedulerProvider.ui)
                .subscribe ({
                    isAdd.onNext(it)
                },{
                    Log.d("addImage",it.message)
                })
        }

    }.addTo(compositeDisposable)
    return Output(isAdd)
}

////////////////////////////// in Activity/Fragment i create /////////////// private fun bindViewModel(){ val output = viewModel.transform( RoomImageViewModel.Input( edImage.textChanges().map { it.toString() }, image, btnInsert.clicks().throttleFirst(300, TimeUnit.MILLISECONDS) ) ) with(output){ isAdd.subscribe { Log.d("AddImage",it.toString()) } isDelete.subscribe { Log.d("Delete",it.toString()) } } } //////////////

androminor commented 4 years ago

@ameybhandarkar the navigator is an interface between the activity and the viewmodel. That is not holding a reference to a context or really anything. There is a special kind of viewmodel called the AndroidViewModel that does hold reference to an applictation context.

androminor commented 4 years ago

just corrected something 👍🏿