Final Project Feedback

[kuldeep23907]

Hi Jarret Moses – I am Kuldeep, a mentor who is assisting with the grading. Congratulations, your Final Project passed! We'll be approving it on the course itself in a week or two, but here's your feedback in the meanwhile:

Frontend Comments:

• Frontend looks cool. Looks like a journal for sure. Really liked it. Works well too.
• Ropsten testnet
• Vercel has been used for the front-end deployment. Github pages can be used to deploy an MVP easily.

Testing comments:

• Structured properly using Describe stt. All test cases pass successfully.
• Coverage of all test cases possible for Smart Contract methods.

Contract Comments:

• Smart contract looks fine. Optimization is needed for sure like a lot of storage will be used.
• Inheritance and access control have been used. Simple design patterns but implemented alright.
• Floating pragma and Modifier used only for validation attack patterns had been addressed.
• Ownable has been used from Openzeppelin.

Overall:

• A unique idea is the key feature of the project.
• Good to have either a MetaMask ""Switch Network"" button or an easier way to users to switch or at least not render content before. I had to refresh the page after changing networks, probably build it in an event listener or some other method to do that automatically.
• The same goes for account change. It will be a good addition to the user experience.
• No issue on the front-end but good to show the user's address on top.
• The idea is good and UI is implemented superbly with good UI/UX. I will suggest you try hackathons after this and try to learn more in the blockchain field.

Hope you enjoyed the learning journey so far and can continue building on this.

[jarretmoses]

@kuldeep23907 thanks a lot for the feedback especially with the storage optimization which I know is definitely something I need to do. I want to expand on the project for sure and refine mostly everything you saw. The course was really well done and am happy to have gone through it. I absolutely plan on continuing my learning and will look to join some hackathons in the future.