search

jascoproducts / firmware

Firmware for connected home devices.
349 stars 31 forks source link

[Bug Report]: UltraPro - ZWA4011 - 59347 - 1.22.2 #130

Open rrendec opened 4 weeks ago

rrendec commented 4 weeks ago

What brand is the bug report for?

UltraPro

ZW Number

ZWA4011

Product Number

59347

FW Version

1.22.2

Bug Report Details

There is a visible delay between the moment when the rocker switch is pressed and the moment when the relay toggles. Ideally there should be no delay. Most people would expect the lights to turn on the moment they press the button.

I am assuming the delay is there because without it it's impossible to differentiate between a single click and a double click, which correspond to different actions.

However, I also own a few 39348 devices, which used to have the same problem, and it was fixed by upgrading to the latest firmware, v5.54. With this firmware, they are still able to differentiate between a single click and a long press (hold) and act as a scene controller, but with no delay between the click and the relay control. From my point of view, this is the ideal behavior, and still allows me to implement more advanced controls (e.g. using something like Z-Wave JS UI and Node-RED). I would buy more 39348 devices, but unfortunately they are no longer available.

Is there any chance you could implement something similar for the 59347 devices? I understand this would break the existing double click function, but the user could choose which firmware to install depending on the behavior they prefer (immediate relay control or double click support). Or even better, the behavior could be selected by a configuration parameter, and then the user would be able to choose the desired behavior very easily.

How To Reproduce

Press the rocker switch once (single click) to toggle the current relay (load) state. The issue is always reproducible.

rrendec commented 3 weeks ago

This could be much easier than I thought initially. It could be enough to expose the double click timeout value as a user configurable parameter over Z-Wave e.g. through the Configuration Command Class. By "double click timeout" I mean the amount of time the device waits for a second click before it identifies the user action as a single click.

I'm thinking that the double click logic could remain unchanged, and if the user wants a faster response on single click and doesn't care about double click, they can just configure the timeout to be shorter.