search

java / devrel

Java DevRel feedback
https://inside.java
10 stars 1 forks source link

[Suggestion]: Keyboard navigation for Run and Clear #11

Open tofflos opened 1 year ago

tofflos commented 1 year ago

What happened?

I have to move my hands from the keyboard, grab the mouse, and click the Run and Clear buttons. Afterwards I have to click the text area to continue editing.

Consider adding a keyboard shortcut such as Control + Return for launching Run and showing the keyboard shortcut as a tooltip. Consider moving the keyboard focus back to text area after launching Run and Clear.

OS

Windows

What browsers are you seeing the problem on?

Firefox

Contact Details (optional)

No response

Additional information

Leave blank

delabassee commented 1 year ago

It's a bit difficult to find bindings that are relatively obvious and free. I suggest Ctrl+Enter for "Run" and Ctrl+Backspace for "Clear", ⌘+Enter & ⌘+Backspace on Mac.

nipafx commented 1 year ago

Ctrl+Enter for "Run" is great but Ctrl+Backspace is already taken for "delete word before cursor" (in most text editors and browsers). You could use Ctrl+Shift+Backspace for that.

delabassee commented 1 year ago

Not a big fan of a 3 keys combo. What about Ctrl+Esc instead?

danthe1st commented 1 year ago

Ctrl+Esc is at least used by Windows for bringing up the start menu.

carimura commented 1 year ago

+1 to command+return on Mac for running -- makes sense and is consistent with other behaviour (like sending this comment). I think sending the focus to the code window after run makes sense.

It's fine If we don't settle on clear for now as cmd+a then delete is a native way to clear the window without having to map anything and it keeps the focus.

delabassee commented 1 year ago

Note that "clear" clears both the editor and the console.

tofflos commented 1 year ago

I'd be super happy with just the Run shortcut and I'm not sure I would use a Clear shortcut often enough to warrant a shortcut.

delabassee commented 1 year ago

Isn't Esc a good "Clear" (console & editor) shortcut?

nipafx commented 1 year ago

Ctrl+Shift+Backspace is not uncommon for larger deletes, e.g. in GitHub comment fields it deletes a line.

Isn't Esc a good "Clear" (console & editor) shortcut?

Only if a popup asks whether you really want to do that. Otherwise Esc is too commonly used to have such destructive effects.

danthe1st commented 1 year ago

I am unsure whether an option to clear the console together with the output is really necessary. After all, the console is cleared anyways when re-running the code.