search

jaybo / deepzoom-blog

Public repository for DeepZoom
0 stars 0 forks source link

NOAA MBTiles Improvements #37

Open jaybo opened 8 months ago

jaybo commented 8 months ago

NOAA has published a set of USA charts in the MBTiles format here: https://distribution.charts.noaa.gov/ncds/index.html

Since there is no way to provide feedback directly to NOAA on these charts, I'm using this DeepZoom Issue to list the problems I've encountered in hope that NOAA will someday notice and implement these improvements.

jaybo commented 8 months ago

Non uniform coverage

Here at zoom 3-4, northern Alaska includes no tiles

image
jaybo commented 8 months ago

Don't display text and markers at low zoom levels

image

Here, at zoom 6.2, the buoy and light text is completely illegible. Don't show any markers or text below zoom 7.

jaybo commented 8 months ago

Make depth text slightly larger

MapBox, and presumably most similar tile display engines, displays a given tile over a zoom range. For example a Z14 tile is displayed between zooms 13.5 and 14.5. At the bottom end of this range, particularly on iPhone and similar hires displays, the depth text is almost illegible. Then, as you zoom up to 14.5 it finally becomes large enough, only to shrink again as the zoom increases beyond 14.5.

image
jaybo commented 8 months ago

Duplication of buoys and cans

This is from Penn Cove, around Coupeville, WA. Presumably the same 2 FL Y 6s is being rendered from two different zoom levels?

image

jaybo commented 3 months ago

Multiple color values represent land

And the newest NOAA MBTiles release in 2024.05 unfortunately doesn't fix any of the above issues. But it also introduces a new wrinkle. Previously, all of the land areas were a uniform shade of beige. But in the latest release, the land is represented by a range of color values, making the land cutout algorithm unnecessarily difficult:

image