search

jboss-dockerfiles / jbpm

MIT License
24 stars 36 forks source link

Kubernetes support #48

Open TheKangaroo opened 6 years ago

TheKangaroo commented 6 years ago

Hey guys, I just wanted to deploy jbpm to my kubernetes cluster, but saw in your doc's at docker hub that

This image is not intended to be run on cloud environments such as RedHat OpenShift or Amazon EC2, as it does not meet all the requirements.

Does this apply to kubernetes as well? Which problems occur on cloud environments? I started the app with replicas: 1, but it failed to log in, as soon as I increased the replica count.

ndass-sapient commented 4 years ago

Hi @TheKangaroo - Is it still an issue? Did you managed to deploy jBPM in Kubernetes cluster?

We want to deploy this in Kubernetes and want to have control over the size of each component of jBPM. For example we would like to assign more pods (or scaling policy) to process executors.

TheKangaroo commented 4 years ago

Hi @ndass-sapient, we had this running as a test setup, but just a single instance and no individual scaling of the components, in other words: a very basic setup. I think there is some work to do on the app side. Since nobody ever responded to this issue I don't think this is a priority for the developers, unfortunately.

bongbk commented 3 years ago

Hi @TheKangaroo, did you fix it ? Can you share , I also have this problem

TheKangaroo commented 3 years ago

@bongbk unfortunately no, we never came back to try to fix this. But as I said early, I don't think this is something you can fix in kubernetes deployment. jbpm just does not support to run with multiple instances at once.

scalasm commented 1 year ago

My feeling is that if you want "JBPM in Kubernetes", then you need to look at Kogito, the kubernetes-ready solution for workflows. It is still BPMN but with Kubernetes-friendly (as long as Kubernetes can be friendly to your team, that is ... but this is another story!