jdecked / twemoji

Emoji for everyone.
https://jdecked.github.io/twemoji/v/latest/preview-svg.html
MIT License
1k stars 60 forks source link

New project name? #111

Open nclm opened 2 months ago

nclm commented 2 months ago

It’s great to see that the open source Twemoji set is continuing life independently from Twitter!

As this set is now developing on its own, and will in time differ more and more with the “official” X emojis, wouldn’t a rename be a good move to distinguish them? And make it clear that this is now an independent project.

The name could either:

A new name could go along a new webpage (#85) to really relaunch the emoji set to the eyes of developers who haven’t been made aware of this fork yet.

jdecked commented 2 months ago

It's definitely on our to-do list! I will say it's not the highest thing, but it's on there. Suggestions welcome! (From anyone reading, not just OP.) When we first started working on this fork we bandied around a few that were admittedly also quite bad 😂

We'd kept Twemoji "for now" just for discoverability purposes. 50/50 on whether that has really worked, but it's probably time for a change.

JiFish commented 2 months ago

Might be worth returning to this now twitter/x is doing weird controversial stuff with it's emojis.

nclm commented 1 month ago

Some extra quick ideas:

Just to get the conversation started :)

SlickDomique commented 1 month ago

Would be great if the project could change name, would be easier to find it on npm too. Right now twitters version is still up and I had to look in closed issues here for npm to learn the npm package is under @twemoji/api

jdecked commented 1 month ago

Would be great if the project could change name, would be easier to find it on npm too. Right now twitters version is still up and I had to look in closed issues here for npm to learn the npm package is under @twemoji/api

This is helpful to know. Out of curiosity, what did you search for on NPM or before going to NPM? Were you searching for open-source emoji packages generally, or specifically for Twemoji?

A major reason we kept the Twemoji name originally was to make this package easier to find, but if that's not actually helping it be found, that'd be great to know.

SlickDomique commented 1 month ago

Would be great if the project could change name, would be easier to find it on npm too. Right now twitters version is still up and I had to look in closed issues here for npm to learn the npm package is under @twemoji/api

This is helpful to know. Out of curiosity, what did you search for on NPM or before going to NPM? Were you searching for open-source emoji packages generally, or specifically for Twemoji?

A major reason we kept the Twemoji name originally was to make this package easier to find, but if that's not actually helping it be found, that'd be great to know.

I was looking for a package to replace emojis with pictures for my hobby project. This was the biggest result anywhere but trying to look by the name for npm package gave only old twitter package. Maybe it's a good idea to add info about installing from npm to the readme file too.

KeesCBakker commented 1 month ago

I had the same, but then for GitHub. It wasn't until reading the issues in the original repo till I found a link to this current repo.

I think Google still favors the original in the search results. When reading about v14 something clicked, as I'm using v15.

JiFish commented 1 month ago

I suggest keeping the name simple and obviously understandable. Freemoji, OpenEmoji, Libremoji or a variation thereof would be nice. But these names are so obvious they've already been used for a bunch of stuff, which might make the project hard to google.

Perhaps "Creative Commons Emoji" or CCemoji for short?

RealityRipple commented 2 weeks ago

Kicking myself for not making an "XTwitMoji" rename Pull Request back on April Fools.