Outlook-style Reply All behavior (preserve To and CC recipients)

[modest]

Enhancement request :) The most annoying behavior in Apple Mail is Reply All. Unlike Outlook, it does not preserve the To/CC line of the message you are replying to. Instead, it moves everyone except the last sender to the CC line.

Example

Received message

From: Alice To: Bob, Cathy, David, YOU CC: Eric, Frank

Outlook Reply-All behavior

From: YOU To: Alice, Bob, Cathy, David CC: Eric, Frank

Apple Mail Reply-All behavior

From: YOU To: Alice CC: Bob, Cathy, David, Eric, Frank

All of the recipients on the To line have been dropped to CC.

[jeevatkm]

Before committing to this behaviour, I will have to verify few internal elements in Mail.app.

Will let you know, currently I labeled as analyze.

[jeevatkm]

Poor internal API support Mail app, however I'm planing to handle via workaround and logic.

Are you interest in try out pre-release version and share your feedback?

[jeevatkm]

It's done!

[modest]

Awesome! Thank you! I will test this out in the next release. Let me know if you want any feedback. :)

[jeevatkm]

Can you please try v5.0-beta and share your feedback? Download Link: https://app.box.com/s/qta2i4osh2lz9f2jojjg1j98fd762sdo

[jeevatkm]

@modest - Did you get a chance to verify the implementation?

[modest]

@jeevatkm The behavior is perfect. I tested all the cases I could find, and they all behaved exactly as expected with Outlook parity. Thank you!

[jeevatkm]

@modest I'm glad it worked as expected :)