jellyfin / jellyfin-webos

WebOS Client for Jellyfin
https://jellyfin.org
Mozilla Public License 2.0
646 stars 68 forks source link

Volume decreasing with every Jellyfin restart on LG TV #233

Closed Karkunow closed 1 month ago

Karkunow commented 3 months ago

Volume decreasing with every Jellyfin restart on LG TV. After some amount of restarts it goes to 0 and there is no sound on any movies.

andaril commented 3 months ago

Experiencing same issue on lg c3. Now i'm having no sound in any video with fine logs.

Karkunow commented 3 months ago

@andaril you can re-install Jellyfin and it helps to solve it for some time

holcus commented 3 months ago

Same issue, reinstall helps. Lg c3

Sebby75 commented 3 months ago

Same issue on LG 43UJ750V (webos 2.0), Jellyfin 1.2.2 from LG appstore, Once it goes silent, the only solution seem to be reinstalling app.

dmitrylyzo commented 3 months ago

I can't reproduce this in the emulator - tried: start app, start video playback, exit app and repeat.

I wonder if volume just changes by wheel, because there's no check if it happens on TV.

Sebby75 commented 3 months ago

I wonder if volume just changes by wheel, because there's no check if it happens on TV.

You are correct !! Just checked this.. wheel does indeed change volume (there is no indication at all on tv screen).. this works completely independent from normal tv volume control (wheel = jellyfin plugin internal volume)

Karkunow commented 3 months ago

@dmitrylyzo @Sebby75 what is the "wheel"? how can I regulate it?

Sebby75 commented 3 months ago

image

It's in the centre of LG Magic Remote

holcus commented 3 months ago

Makes sense I was using down wheel to get the cursor up. It's not a bug, it's a feature

Sebby75 commented 3 months ago

Makes sense I was using down wheel to get the cursor up. It's not a bug, it's a feature

Well.. no other app has this (Netflix, Prime Video)... I don't really understand why second independent volume control is needed. Especially when there is no indication on the screen that you are actually changing anything,

dmitrylyzo commented 3 months ago

It is definitely a bug - TV has a physical volume control. Until some time, TV remotes didn't have a wheel on them, so it didn't bother anyone.

Karkunow commented 3 months ago

Omg, it wasn't obvious at all! :) But yes - wheel up - and it is working now. On LG TV I can't see any kind of volume change in UI while using the wheel - but it changes.

thethingexe commented 3 months ago

I uninstalled Jellyfin-WebOS 1.2.2 and installed 1.1.0 and the wheel changing the volume is also in that version.

Has this feature always existed? Or was this a new feature in Jellyfin Server 10.9.X?

dmitrylyzo commented 3 months ago

Or was this a new feature in Jellyfin Server 10.9.X?

Yes, it was added in 10.9 (https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-web/pull/4435).

I uninstalled Jellyfin-WebOS 1.2.2 and installed 1.1.0 and the wheel changing the volume is also in that version.

The app is just a wrapper, so it takes the UI from the server. The app may have some minor changes to adjust something platform specific.

Qrrbrbirlbel commented 2 months ago

I know this will be fixed in 10.9.9 …

Just checked this.. wheel does indeed change volume (there is no indication at all on tv screen).

I had the same problem. Had to turn up my TV sound extremely to the point that I could hear some white noise. Uninstalled Homebrew Jellyfin and installed proper and it was fixed so I didn't give it much thought.

However, visiting the server via the built-in browser dialing the wheel does bring up a graphical element that shows this. Which finally made me test the wheel in the proper app and figuring this out for myself.

It is an interesting feature if you know about it but it's also quite pointless since the TV has its own volume control.

holcus commented 2 months ago

It has use if you passthrough sound to avr/soundbar

Randalix commented 1 month ago

I had the same problem. Needed to increase my Tv volume to insane amounts. Imo controlling volume with the wheel shoudl be either removed or there needs to be a visual indicator that shows the change happening. Wihtout this thread I would have never assumed that the volume can be changed with the magic remotes center wheel.

dmitrylyzo commented 1 month ago

Fixed by https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-web/pull/5740