Closed jeremybanka closed 4 days ago
The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git โ๏ธ
Name | Status | Preview | Comments | Updated (UTC) |
---|---|---|---|---|
atom-io-fyi | โ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | ๐ฌ Add feedback | Aug 20, 2024 0:41am |
wayfarer-quest | โ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | ๐ฌ Add feedback | Aug 20, 2024 0:41am |
Latest commit: 649ded1603792ecbb5e92457f34801d313026ae9
The changes in this PR will be included in the next version bump.
Not sure what this means? Click here to learn what changesets are.
Click here if you're a maintainer who wants to add another changeset to this PR
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review **Possible Bug:** The `exposeMutable` function is used to expose mutable state for `usersInRoomsAtoms` with `username`. Ensure that the username is properly sanitized or validated to prevent potential misuse or data leakage. **Code Clarity:** The refactoring of `myRoomKeyState` in `my-room.ts` simplifies the logic but could benefit from additional comments to explain the changes, especially how the new logic handles null and undefined values. **Performance Concern:** The `syncContinuity` function in `sync-continuity.ts` has complex logic for handling state updates. Review the performance implications of these updates, especially in scenarios with high frequency updates. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Enhance the
___
**The function | 10 |
Simplify the JSX structure by making NullWrapper self-closing___ **Ensure that the NullWrapper component is self-closing if it does not need to wrap anychildren, which simplifies the JSX structure.** [packages/hamr/react-json-editor/src/editors-by-type/primitive-editors.tsx [25]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2223/files#diff-d0043f55c27bd0c80b4f339d3621ef6d0c155bdcec894fff0851f054859ef47aR25-R25) ```diff - Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: The suggestion correctly simplifies the JSX structure by making the NullWrapper component self-closing, which is a clear improvement in code clarity and maintainability. | 10 | |
Modify the
___
**The | 8 | |
Adjust the button's disabled condition to match the roomId for clarity and correct functionality___ **Thedisabled property for the button is set based on myRoomKey !== null . This logic might not correctly reflect the intended behavior, especially if myRoomKey should specifically match roomId to enable the button. Consider revising the condition to ensure it aligns with the functional requirements.** [apps/wayfarer.quest/src/app/Room.tsx [59]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2223/files#diff-3da64db6f6d61a90003ad559d41a216e2820abee387693fb9f470e86982ca302R59-R59) ```diff -disabled={myRoomKey !== null} +disabled={myRoomKey !== roomId} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves the clarity and functionality of the button's disabled state by ensuring it matches the roomId, which is a minor but useful enhancement. | 7 | |
Possible bug |
Add a check to ensure the state exists before exposing it as mutable to prevent runtime errors___ **It seems that theexposeMutable function is being used without checking if the state exists or if the username is valid. This could lead to runtime errors if findState(usersInRoomsAtoms, username) returns null or an undefined value. It's recommended to add a check to ensure the state exists before exposing it as mutable.** [apps/core.wayfarer.quest/src/system.server.ts [65]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2223/files#diff-6ec367858c982ba29a722c8bb86651414505a99e97dfb05d332a27d4ce3ecb24R65-R65) ```diff -exposeMutable(findState(usersInRoomsAtoms, username)) +const userRoomState = findState(usersInRoomsAtoms, username); +if (userRoomState) { + exposeMutable(userRoomState); +} else { + console.error('Invalid username or state not found:', username); +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a potential runtime error by ensuring that the state exists before exposing it as mutable. This is a critical improvement for robustness. | 9 |
Maintainability |
Improve the readability and consistency of class name construction___ **Use template literals consistently for constructing class names. This improves readabilityand consistency in the code.** [packages/hamr/react-json-editor/src/default-components.tsx [60]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2223/files#diff-3fb5e9ec5ea462befeb2afe2403bf6a8128230600faa4fd6fa0ca4c45b63debbR60-R60) ```diff -
+
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion improves readability and consistency by using template literals in a more concise manner, which is beneficial for maintainability. | 8 |
User description
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix, Tests, Configuration changes
Description
exposeMutable
forusersInRoomsAtoms
withusername
.myRoomKeyState
selector logic for clarity.undefined
andnull
data inStateEditor
.realtimeContinuitySynchronizer
.SyncGroup
class andadd
method logic.runTransaction
method toSilo
class.EditorWrapper
.NullEditor
component.Changes walkthrough ๐
7 files
system.server.ts
Expose mutable state for users in rooms.
apps/core.wayfarer.quest/src/system.server.ts - Added `exposeMutable` for `usersInRoomsAtoms` with `username`.
Room.tsx
Enhance room component with username state and mutable atoms.
apps/wayfarer.quest/src/app/Room.tsx
findState
andmyUsernameState
imports.myRoomKey
logic to usefindRelations
.usePullMutableAtomFamilyMember
forusersInRoomsInternal
.my-room.ts
Refactor myRoomKeyState selector logic.
apps/wayfarer.quest/src/services/store/my-room.ts - Refactored `myRoomKeyState` selector logic for clarity.
sync-continuity.ts
Enhance sync continuity with molecule and family member
initialization.
packages/atom.io/realtime-client/src/sync-continuity.ts
growMoleculeInStore
andinitFamilyMemberInStore
functions.initializeContinuity
andreveal
event handling.upsertState
function for state updates.realtime-continuity-synchronizer.ts
Improve realtime continuity synchronizer initial payload and
transaction handling.
packages/atom.io/realtime-server/src/realtime-continuity-synchronizer.ts
realtimeContinuitySynchronizer
.realtime-continuity.ts
Simplify SyncGroup class and add method logic.
packages/atom.io/realtime/src/realtime-continuity.ts - Simplified `SyncGroup` class and `add` method logic.
silo.ts
Add runTransaction method to Silo class.
packages/atom.io/src/silo.ts - Added `runTransaction` method to `Silo` class.
1 files
realtime-continuity.test.tsx
Add tests for mutable atoms in continuity.
packages/atom.io/__tests__/experimental/realtime/realtime-continuity.test.tsx
3 files
StateEditor.tsx
Improve StateEditor handling of undefined and null data.
packages/atom.io/react-devtools/src/StateEditor.tsx - Improved handling of `undefined` and `null` data in `StateEditor`.
default-components.tsx
Fix className handling in EditorWrapper.
packages/hamr/react-json-editor/src/default-components.tsx - Fixed className handling in `EditorWrapper`.
primitive-editors.tsx
Fix rendering of NullEditor component.
packages/hamr/react-json-editor/src/editors-by-type/primitive-editors.tsx - Fixed rendering of `NullEditor` component.
2 files
dry-news-dress.md
Add changeset for mutable atoms in realtime continuity.
.changeset/dry-news-dress.md
continuity.
long-dogs-wait.md
Add changeset for Silo runTransaction method.
.changeset/long-dogs-wait.md - Added changeset for adding `runTransaction` method to `Silo`.
1 files
.env.dev
Add environment variables for development.
apps/core.wayfarer.quest/.env.dev - Added environment variables for `PORT` and `CLIENT_ORIGINS`.