Closed jeremybanka closed 1 month ago
Latest commit: b702d2d90a2156f92a51c94ee0802e170dcac5c5
The changes in this PR will be included in the next version bump.
Not sure what this means? Click here to learn what changesets are.
Click here if you're a maintainer who wants to add another changeset to this PR
The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git โ๏ธ
Name | Status | Preview | Comments | Updated (UTC) |
---|---|---|---|---|
atom-io-fyi | โ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | ๐ฌ Add feedback | Aug 13, 2024 9:50pm |
wayfarer-quest | โ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | ๐ฌ Add feedback | Aug 13, 2024 9:50pm |
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Test Coverage Ensure that the test cases cover all new error scenarios introduced for family key conflicts, including edge cases and different types of families. Error Handling Review the error handling logic to ensure that it correctly identifies and throws errors for all types of family conflicts, not just atom families. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Error handling |
Implement error handling for selector creation___ **Add error handling for thecreateWritableSelector function to manage exceptions that might occur during selector creation.** [packages/atom.io/internal/src/families/create-writable-selector-family.ts [41-49]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2397/files#diff-cb43db3aca301de32b560837206d9ab8d7e46ea942867973aea122a720c31052R41-R49) ```diff -const token = createWritableSelector( - { - key: fullKey, - get: options.get(key), - set: options.set(key), - }, - family, - target, -) +let token; +try { + token = createWritableSelector( + { + key: fullKey, + get: options.get(key), + set: options.set(key), + }, + family, + target, + ); +} catch (error) { + console.error(`Failed to create writable selector: ${error}`); + throw error; +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Adding error handling for the `createWritableSelector` function is crucial for managing exceptions and improving the reliability of the code. | 9 |
Possible bug |
Add type safety check for function invocation___ **Ensure that the type ofdef is checked before invoking it as a function to prevent runtime errors if def is not a function.**
[packages/atom.io/internal/src/families/create-regular-atom-family.ts [44]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2397/files#diff-1534b05697a5730de7721e61a41b1061226b23b32e4a8b8d80d5a5e6bb2caf9aR44-R44)
```diff
-default: def instanceof Function ? def(key) : def,
+default: typeof def === 'function' ? def(key) : def,
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Ensuring the type of `def` is checked before invoking it as a function prevents potential runtime errors, enhancing code robustness. | 8 |
Best practice |
Ensure
___
**Consider using a more specific type check for | 8 |
Maintainability |
Refactor repeated error messages into a constant___ **Consider refactoring the repeated error message into a constant to avoid duplicationand facilitate easier maintenance or localization of error messages.** [packages/atom.io/__tests__/private/grace.test.ts [176-214]](https://github.com/jeremybanka/wayforge/pull/2397/files#diff-704681e68b526dd6ec35340de49c6e296c5f461e7ad23fc3c7bb75e249506176R176-R214) ```diff -`Tried to create an Atom Family with key "count", but "count" already exists in store "IMPLICIT_STORE" as an Atom Family` -`Tried to create a Readonly Selector Family with key "count", but "count" already exists in store "IMPLICIT_STORE" as an Atom Family` -`Tried to create a Mutable Atom Family with key "count", but "count" already exists in store "IMPLICIT_STORE" as an Atom Family` -`Tried to create a Selector Family with key "count", but "count" already exists in store "IMPLICIT_STORE" as an Atom Family` +const errorMessage = `Tried to create a family with key "count", but "count" already exists in store "IMPLICIT_STORE" as a family`; +... +}).toThrowError(errorMessage) +... +}).toThrowError(errorMessage) +... +}).toThrowError(errorMessage) +... +}).toThrowError(errorMessage) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Refactoring repeated error messages into a constant improves maintainability and readability, but it is not crucial for functionality. | 7 |
User description
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
prettyPrintTokenType
function to a separate file for better modularity.Changes walkthrough ๐
1 files
grace.test.ts
Add tests for family key conflict error handling
packages/atom.io/__tests__/private/grace.test.ts
with duplicate keys.
selectorFamily
andSetRTX
for new test cases.8 files
create-readonly-selector-family.ts
Handle key conflicts in readonly selector family creation
packages/atom.io/internal/src/families/create-readonly-selector-family.ts
throwInCaseOfConflictingFamily
function call to handle keyconflicts.
create-regular-atom-family.ts
Handle key conflicts in regular atom family creation
packages/atom.io/internal/src/families/create-regular-atom-family.ts
throwInCaseOfConflictingFamily
function call to handle keyconflicts.
create-writable-selector-family.ts
Handle key conflicts in writable selector family creation
packages/atom.io/internal/src/families/create-writable-selector-family.ts
throwInCaseOfConflictingFamily
function call to handle keyconflicts.
throw-in-case-of-conflicting-family.ts
Add utility to throw errors on family key conflicts
packages/atom.io/internal/src/families/throw-in-case-of-conflicting-family.ts
index.ts
Export prettyPrint utility
packages/atom.io/internal/src/index.ts - Exported `prettyPrint` utility.
create-mutable-atom-family.ts
Handle key conflicts in mutable atom family creation
packages/atom.io/internal/src/mutable/create-mutable-atom-family.ts
throwInCaseOfConflictingFamily
function call to handle keyconflicts.
not-found-error.ts
Refactor prettyPrintTokenType to separate file
packages/atom.io/internal/src/not-found-error.ts
prettyPrintTokenType
to a separate file for better modularity.pretty-print.ts
Add prettyPrintTokenType utility function
packages/atom.io/internal/src/pretty-print.ts - Created new file for `prettyPrintTokenType` function.
1 files
perfect-birds-double.md
Add changeset for family key conflict error handling
.changeset/perfect-birds-double.md
conflicts.