search

jfedor2 / hid-remapper

USB input remapping dongle
Other
1.07k stars 126 forks source link

Single Pico design not working on USB Power (Works on Dual Pico design) #100

Open davidz-yt opened 10 months ago

davidz-yt commented 10 months ago

I've been testing HID Remapper (r2023-11-08 and 11-15) in a setup where it's connected to just USB Power on the output (instead of connecting it to a PC). Similar to your Xbox Adaptive Controller setup, I'm trying to remap from a USB device to the GPIO outputs. The issue I'm finding is that this does not work on the Single Pico design, but works perfectly fine on the Dual Pico design. Is this expected behavior?

Both the Single and Dual Pico designs work perfectly with GPIO outputs when the output is also connected to a PC. It's just when you use USB Power (or the PC is asleep) the Single design stops working, but the Dual is fine.

Scenarios Tested: Working: USB Keyboard -> HID Remapper (Single Pico) -> GPIO Output & PC USB Working: USB Keyboard -> HID Remapper (Dual Pico) -> GPIO Output & PC USB NOT Working: USB Keyboard -> HID Remapper (Single Pico) -> GPIO Output & USB Power Working: USB Keyboard -> HID Remapper (Dual Pico) -> GPIO Output & USB Power

jfedor2 commented 10 months ago

I haven't considered this use case before, but knowing how it works underneath it actually makes sense. It's because the remapping engine iterations are synced to different things on these variants, on the dual Pico version they're synced to the USB clock of the host port on the B-side Pico and on the single Pico variant they're synced to the clock of the USB host port of the PC. So when there's no USB connection the remapping engine doesn't run.

I will think about it, it should be possible to make it work.

davidz-yt commented 10 months ago

Thanks for the explanation. I had a hunch it'd be because of something like that. Regardless, I'm ecstatic it works with the dual Pico variant. Keep up the great work, this solution is amazing!