jgyates / genmon

Generac (and other models) Generator Monitoring using a Raspberry Pi and WiFi
GNU General Public License v2.0
379 stars 76 forks source link

Genmon not recognizing current engine state #763

Closed skipfire closed 2 years ago

skipfire commented 2 years ago

Genmon did not show the generator as running during my weekly idle test, it showed as Auto, Off-Ready. The screenshot was taken while the generator was running.

Using Start Generator from the maintenance page it did show the generator as running.

The monitor page shows 0 errors.

In this past it shows the correct status in Genmon during weekly idle tests, this is the first weekly test since I got my new controller.

image

Expected Behavior

Genmon should see the correct state

Actual Behavior

Genmon didn't recognize the generator was running

Steps to Reproduce (including precondition)

My weekly 5-minute maintenance is when I detected this.

Your Environment

jgyates commented 2 years ago

Hi @skipfire ,

A few questions

1) Is there any relevant info in the logs of errors? 2) How is your system wired (direct serial, modbus TCP, is the pi close to the generator, etc) 3) Can you duplicate this or is this just a single instance 4) when you noticed this, was the monitor time at the bottom of the status page updating every 5 seconds (if not then your web page is not updating which would indicate a browser issue) 5) were any of the gauges moving at all 6) did you get any notices regarding generator changing state (emails or txt messages) if you have that setup to do so

skipfire commented 2 years ago
  1. none of the logs show anything around that time
  2. wired direct serial with a 1M cable
  3. I'll look at duplicating, it happened with the weekly test but not when manually started with Genmon
  4. I did not notice, but I did do a full refresh and I switched computers to take the screenshot so I can rule out anything client specific.
  5. CPU temp, WiFi signal, and battery moved a bit, but none of the running gauges moved. Usually I see 0.02kW output when it is idle and did not see that.
  6. No messages about state change from the weekly test, but when I started with the maintenance page the status text, gauges, and notifications all worked correctly.

I just updated my generator's test time for about 5 minutes from now, I'll see what happens then.

skipfire commented 2 years ago

Odd, exercised again and it worked correctly. I'm still curious why it registered as not running the first time, but oh well. I'll just call it a glitch for now.