Provide feedback for the first round of georeference data representation and end point

jhu-digital-manuscripts / AnIOp

to track the activities of the Mellon funded Annotation Interoperability project

0 stars 0 forks source link

Provide feedback for the first round of georeference data representation and end point #67

Closed cyork closed 4 years ago

cyork commented 4 years ago

Please review the proposed web annotation representation of Georeference data as described here https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BeyLcSTBnSCZnkYjeqHu-oTKuDfdSKvZGmBWdZ6YmLE/edit#.

Please note the section titled "Proposed use of Web Annotation" for some specific areas items/questions that should be considered when reviewing the proposal and giving feedback.

Please comment directly on the doc to start. We'll follow up with comments, slack messages and/or meetings request as appropriate.

Thanks!

jacobwegner commented 4 years ago

I've just left some feedback from the Eldarion team. Just to summarize:

We think that focusing this annotation on places and leaving #54 for persons may result in a more straightforward implementation for a client.
Mapping TextPositionSelector values to the English translation (https://scaife.perseus.org/reader/urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0012.tlg001.perseus-eng4:2.480-2.840/) would make the annotation more useful
With that mapping, it would be easier to resolve the annotation to a particular folio

jacobwegner commented 4 years ago

(and we're happy to discuss any possible mapping approaches further on a call or in Slack)

markpatton commented 4 years ago

Useful feedback. I've updated the google doc with some followup.