search

jingyu987 / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

edit-item and edit-stall can confuse users #5

Open jingyu987 opened 12 months ago

jingyu987 commented 12 months ago

UG states that edit-item can be used to update existing items.

image.png

But when i attempt to edit an item, it tells me that there is no review to edit and requires users to add a review first.

image.png

This is submitted as a feature flaw as it doesn't always do what is intended, I believe users should be able to edit descriptions or ratings even if there is none given yet for both edit-stalls and edit-item.

nus-pe-bot commented 12 months ago

Team's Response

Already mentioned in the UG that you need to have an existing review before you can edit it (shown in the blue box)

image.png

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: The intended purpose of this bug report was not to criticise the documentation but more so about the design of this particular feature. Would it not be better for the user to be able to edit the rating and review even if one is not added yet coming from an end user's perspective? In essence editing it would also somewhat be considered "adding a review".

image.png

image.png