jobobby04 / TachiyomiSY

Free and open source manga reader for Android
Apache License 2.0
2.84k stars 153 forks source link

Revert 'Downloaded Only' mode to how it used to function #1009

Closed MD-1909 closed 10 months ago

MD-1909 commented 10 months ago

Describe your suggested feature

Before SY v1.10 or Tachi v15, the 'Downloaded Only' toggle would show you the mangas with downloaded chapters and within each entry, just the downloaded chapters. However, you could continue reading back or ahead of the downloaded content (it would start loading pages similar to reading online), as long as you had an internet connection. Screenshot_20240114_141903_Tachiyomi

But now, using downloaded only does not allow you to backread online chapters and instead forces you to go and turn the toggle off, then go back to the manga, scroll all the way to the chapter you need and then open it. Screenshot_20240114_141858_TachiyomiSY

This feels like a step backwards and it really ruins my reading experience. I'm sure that not a lot of people care about this but if it isnt too difficult to revert this to how it was before, I would greatly appreciate it.

TL; DR - Downloaded only is working as it should, I just dislike the fact that it revokes your access to any of the other chapters as if they don't exist in the manga at all, which was not a case for 3 whole years.

Other details

No response

Acknowledgements

NeKoOuO commented 10 months ago

+1

Eragonnogare commented 10 months ago

I disagree on this - if you just want to filter your library to only show manga with downloaded chapters you can use the library filter to do just that still. The "downloaded chapters only" toggle in the current state can allow easier managing of duplicate chapters (for example from different groups) by simply only downloading from the group you want, so the others get filtered out while reading.

MD-1909 commented 10 months ago
  1. The filter is a 3 state switch meaning I have to toggle it to twice to reset the library to its original state unlike the downloaded only button.
  2. It only filters the mangas, not the list of chapters inside each one, meaning I have to change that filter everytime as well, which also is a 3 state switch.
  3. I simply expect the downloaded only button to change visibility of mangas and their chapters, not change what you can access.
jobobby04 commented 10 months ago

I like the download-only filter as it is