johnmcfarlane / papers

9 stars 1 forks source link

LEWGI Kona 2019 Feedback #37

Closed johnmcfarlane closed 5 years ago

johnmcfarlane commented 5 years ago

http://wiki.edg.com/bin/view/Wg21kona2019/P0828R1

"In a future version, I would like to see more prior art and field experience, not just C++." WRT existing fixed-point implementations in other languages/libs.

Stress that non-standard fundamental integers and class-based integers are a reason for composition.

"We would need a sketch of a type family, and example use cases. What you and John should do, for this particular part of the API, split it out into a separate paper."