dynamic index_class_mapping ?

[dgoosens]

hello,

so I need to build a lot of indexes...
the naming of these indexes is dynamic, but I do use a predefined prefix av_%%indexname%% all the indexes do use the same mapping and map to the same class

as the naming is dynamic, I can not list all of them in the configuration...
at runtime, the request tells me on which index I should use.

requests work fine...
BUT when building the resultSet at the end of \Elastica\Search::search, using the injected BuilderInterface the request fails because the class mapping is unknown

so before looking into injecting a custom BuilderInterface, I was wondering if there were ways to either use wildcards for the mapping or inject a mapping at runtime ?

thanks a lot Dmitri

[dgoosens]

hello

So I managed to handle this with a custom ResultSetBuilder that uses a custom IndexNameMapper
Creating these was rather straightforward

In my case, all I had to do was overwriting IndexNameMapper::getClassFromIndexName() to return the class I wanted
(could have gone through the trouble of matching the prefix and/or a dynamic class map)

then, when consuming the service, instead of doing

$index = $this->esClient->getIndex($indexName);
$query = .... ;
$response = $index->search($query, ['limit' => 30], Request::GET);

did

$index = $this->esClient->getIndex($indexName);
$query = .... ;

$search = $index->createSearch($query, ['limit' => 30], $myCustomResultBuilder);
$response = $search->search('', null, Request::GET);

yet.... I find this really over-complicated, just to inject a custom class mapping at runtime
I see two options to avoid this trouble:

1. allow the injection of a class to be used by the ResultBuilder directly in the search() method
2. allow the injection of class-mapping into the IndexNameMapper, but this is currently no possible (or I did not figure out how)

If PRs are accepted for either option, let me know...
think I should be able to deal with this

[damienalexandre]

Hello, thanks for this detailed report!

This library does not support wildcard for class to index mapping as you found out.

I find this really over-complicated, just to inject a custom class mapping at runtime

You should be able to do the second one. The ResultSetBuilder is one of the required argument of the Client: https://github.com/jolicode/elastically/blob/2a97fc8ee18eb5abb5b7b52e7d398fa96d1018e5/src/Client.php#L34

So you can just inject your custom one when creating the Client, which depending on your framework / context may differ.

[dgoosens]

hi @damienalexandre

thanks for getting back at me....
and yes, as you can see in my update, that's what I did

yet... this does not seem very efficient

so wondered if I submit a PR to enable:

• prefix matching
• regex matching

it would have a chance to be merged...
or if this is a deliberate choice by the devs to keep this as simple as possible ?

[damienalexandre]

We tend to avoid adding options and features to keep the library easy to maintain :grimacing: - so my first answer would be to not accept such PR.

BUT there is room for improvement, we could do like we did for the mapping provider.

We added a MappingProviderInterface allowing users to bring their own mapping the way the want (Yaml, Php, Json... whatever).

We could add a IndexNameMapperInterface, and make it easier / clearer how to switch from one to another.

WDYT?

Cheers.

[dgoosens]

We tend to avoid adding options and features to keep the library easy to maintain 😬 - so my first answer would be to not accept such PR.

BUT there is room for improvement, we could do like we did for the mapping provider.

We added a MappingProviderInterface allowing users to bring their own mapping the way the want (Yaml, Php, Json... whatever).

We could add a IndexNameMapperInterface, and make it easier / clearer how to switch from one to another.

WDYT?

Cheers.

I can do that....
not sure I will be able to deal with this immediately, but soon though