search

joogps / MQTT-Climate-Sync

A Home Assistant component for syncing MQTT IR transmitters/receivers with climate entities.
7 stars 0 forks source link

Home Assistant Climate State only changes temporarely #2

Open joaomruas opened 4 years ago

joaomruas commented 4 years ago

Making a hass state set on a SmartIR Climate entity appears to be only a temporary change.

Because less than one minute later the climate entity will be externally updated with the previous state.

Does this implementation work?

joogps commented 4 years ago

That's strange... I don't have this problem here. Did you check your MQTT device log to see if there are any extra state reports?

(tu fala português?)

joaomruas commented 4 years ago

Falo, mas sou de Portugal. Estranho, precisava de saber que funcionava, pode ser do meu sistema... Vou ver. Uso SmartIR + Tasmota.

joogps commented 4 years ago

Tu podias tentar usar o evento que é acionado sempre que a entidade é atualizada pra checar se essa mudança vem da integração mesmo.

Faz uma automação com mqtt_climate_sync_state_changed como trigger e chama algum serviço do domínio notify pra tu conseguir “debugar”

nagyrobi commented 4 years ago

Same here. After a few seconds, it turns back to previous state. See screenshot below: the "turned off" state don't know where it appeared from, it wasn't triggered from the remote.

kép

It looks like SmartIR wants to keep it in previous state perhaps? But note that actual turn off command wasn't sent out neither by remote nor by SmartIR.

joogps commented 4 years ago

@nagyrobi maybe you could try to create an automation with the mqtt_climate_sync_state_changed event and see where the changes are coming from. I'll take a look at SmartIR code to try to figure out what's happening, but, for me, it works fine.

joogps commented 4 years ago

@joaomruas @nagyrobi have you ever tried to use the Tasmota-IRHVAC component? It handles IR messages natively and is way better than SmartIR with MQTT.

nagyrobi commented 4 years ago

didn't try yet. But I will...

nagyrobi commented 4 years ago

I tried with Tasmota-IRHVAC. MQTT-Climate-Sync diesn't work at all with it. I am using vendor GREE commands.

Tasmota-IRHVAC is not bad actually, but lacks some flexibility I was able to receive using SmartIR.