search

joomla / joomla-cms

Home of the Joomla! Content Management System
https://www.joomla.org
GNU General Public License v2.0
4.76k stars 3.65k forks source link

Captcha - Cloudflare Turnstile #38915

Closed joombler closed 1 year ago

joombler commented 2 years ago

Using currenctly Google Recaptcha v3, but would like to switch to Cloudflare Turnstile. @ https://www.cloudflare.com/products/turnstile/

Is there a work around for that in J! 4.2.3 or do I have to make an official request for this?

nikosdion commented 2 years ago

As a contributor to the project, I will tell you what I have been told several times in the past: the Joomla project does not accept and will not implement features which rely on third party services.

Most recently, when I submitted the Multi-factor Authentication feature, I could not include my (already written and used in production) plugins for sending a six-digit code by PushBullet or the SMSAPI.com service as they relied on these external, third party services.

This policy was created before Joomla 3.2 and exempts any features which were already present. reCAPTCHA integration predated the policy so it's still maintained and distributed with Joomla.

I would recommend checking with a third party developer who has already created CAPTCHA plugins for Joomla and ask them if they are interested in creating a plugin for CloudFlare Turnstile.

brianteeman commented 2 years ago

a plugin for cloudfare turnstile already exists https://github.com/SharkyKZ/joomla-turnstile-plugin

i have not tested it etc i just saw it in my feed

joombler commented 2 years ago

Thanks, the author already has responded too. I am not a programmer and for sake of security I'd rather await the come out of its functionallity before implementing it. Of course no offense meant to the creator of the pluging.

joomdonation commented 1 year ago

As answered above, this feature would not be implemented in core. Please use the recommended third party plugin instead. I'm closing this issue.