search

joomla / joomla-cms

Home of the Joomla! Content Management System
https://www.joomla.org
GNU General Public License v2.0
4.77k stars 3.65k forks source link

Improve Messaging For User Actions Log #44465

Open dautrich opened 3 days ago

dautrich commented 3 days ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

On one of my sites, I have set Email Notifications under "User Actions Log Options" of my Super User account to "Yes". Reason: I wanted to get a notification as soon as my deputy has written or changed an article, a module or something else. Image Instead, I was flooded with emails when I worked on the website myself. IMHO this option should be fine-tuned to get better results.

Describe the solution you'd like

In addition to the "Events to Email" there should be additional options:

Additional context

The requested information can possibly be found in the User Actions Log by filtering for the requested user. Note that there is no possibility to select for user groups in this dialogue (which might become an additional feature request). Anyway, I'd prefer an email notification over an active search, as long as I can tune the number of emails to my needs.

brianteeman commented 3 days ago

Are you really sure that you want this? Just as you were flooded with emails when you worked on the site you will be flooded by emails when anyone else works on the site.

dautrich commented 3 days ago

@brianteeman At least I don't get an email every time I (myself) save an article or a module or ....

brianteeman commented 3 days ago

For all the reasons that you dont want to get an email every second when you do something you wont want an email every time a colleague does something. The user action log is not designed for what you want. Workflows is designed for this.

dautrich commented 3 days ago

I don't think your approach is correct. IMHO workflow has been built for a totally different use case. Let's come back to email notifications. That is an existing feature which -at the time being- is not very useful. My proposal is to make that feature a little bit more efficient with limited cost.

We could improve it for example by setting a time limit of n minutes and collect all the log messages within that timeframe, before sending an email. But this would things much more complicated.

brianteeman commented 3 days ago

UAL has certainly not been built for what you are asking